Mac Pro running very slow after El Capitan install
My portable Mac Pro (before mid-2013) was working fine until I installed 3-weeks to El Capitan. Now the spinning color wheel open almost all the time when I switch to another operation.
Run and view the results here so that we know more about your configuration.
This is the Office Mac Pro forum. I asked that your post be moved to the MacBook Pro laptop forum.
Tags: Notebooks
Similar Questions
-
My Mac has been very slow after install creative cloud!
My Mac was very slow after I installed the creative cloud! I can't use my computer normally.
I uninstalled all the programs Adobe but my computer is still slow. I am not able, even using the internet.Hi MicheleJaqueline,
We would like to know the creative cloud version that has been installed on your computer and the version of the OS you are using.
We ask you to start in safe mode and share the results.
Thank you.
-
ZoomBrowser ex running very slow after reloading.
Recently restored my HP 2000 return to settings factory & all works well except the Canon Zoombrowser ex, running very slow. Had no problem before reloading. Any suggestions?
Hello stephanie,.
You may simply update to the latest version to fix this problem. Visit the Canon Website, here, for the latest version information.
You will need to follow this link and enter your model information when prompted.
-
Mac pro running very very slow
Hello
I have a Macbook Pro 4 GB of RAM, after 2016-004 mac update, security update is very very slow.
I had downloaded El Capitan, but have not installed. Mac slow start, I installed the Version of El Capitan 10.11.2 running, it took 1.5 days to install, always very slow operation.
Please advise,
Thanking you,
Concerning
Saket
The startup disk may be necessary repair.
Come on in/Applications/Utilities, then start the Disk Utility app.
Select the disk to boot on the left then click the first aid tab, and then click run.
-
Satellite L855-14R: games running very slow after installing Win 7
Hi guys,.
I have the L855-14R satellite, which came with windows pre-installed 8.
I used win 8 during a time and games have been works ok.
So I decided to install a copy of windows 7 ultimate 64-bit.I downloaded all the drivers from toshiba support and it seems to work fine until I started the same game I played before.
He was running very very slow even on low graphics settings.
No idea of what went wrong after the win 7 installation?
Have Hmm you installed the driver of ATI graphics card?
Maybe the game uses the Intel HD internal graphic that is part of the Intel Core i7-3630QM processor? -
After effects CC running very slow with El Capitan!
Apple and Adobe, we have to answer you as soon as possible! We need this fixed number like yesterday. Since we have updated to the new os El Capitan after effects, first CC and encoder render times doubled. Our workload is now saved, and we need a quick repair. Help, please
I found the solution smh... Adobe originally had the Mercury Playback accelerated GPU (OpenCL)-updated rendering engine after having upgraded to the new operating system and Adobe CC the default rendering engine update affects the MERCURY PLAYBACK ENGINE SOFTWARE ONLY. Just change the rendering engine to Mercury Playback accelerated GPU (OpenCL) and bingo your back in the game will thank me later. Peace.
-
Hello!
I loved using my MacBook Pro. It's REALLY slow. I read all the posts on how to solve the problem and we have tried most of them. Still slow. Nothing wrong with the battery, speakers, etc. Simply slow to move, slow to open apps, beachball for days, takes forever to edit video and audio. I ran EtreCheck as suggested by another user, and here's the summary. Any help would be MUCH appreciated!
Thank you!
K
EtreCheck version: 2.9.12 (265)
Report generated 2016-06-18 09:39:51
Download https://etrecheck.com EtreCheck
Time 11:07
Performance: poor
Click the [Support] links to help with non-Apple products.
Click the [details] links for more information on this line.
Problem: The computer is too slow
Description:
Slow to start and open applications
Hardware information: ⓘ
MacBook Pro (13-inch, mid-2012)
[Technical details] - [User Guide] - [warranty & Service]
MacBook Pro - model: MacBookPro9, 2
1 2.9 GHz Intel Core i7 CPU: 2 strands
8 GB of RAM expandable - [Instructions]
BANK 0/DIMM0
OK 4 GB DDR3 1600 MHz
BANK 1/DIMM0
OK 4 GB DDR3 1600 MHz
Bluetooth: Good - transfer/Airdrop2 taken in charge
Wireless: en1: 802.11 a/b/g/n
Battery: Health = Normal - Cycle count = 405
Video information: ⓘ
Graphics Intel HD 4000
Color LCD 1280 x 800
System software: ⓘ
OS X El Capitan 10.11.5 (15F34) - time since started: about 7 days
Disk information: ⓘ
ST1000LM024 disk HARD APPLE disk0: (1 TB) (rotation)
EFI (disk0s1) < not mounted >: 210 MB
Recovery HD (disk0s3) < not mounted > [recovery]: 650 MB
Macintosh HD (disk 1) /: 998,97 go-go (245,62 free)
Storage of carrots: disk0s2 999.35 GB Online
HL-DT-ST DVD - RW GS31N)
USB information: ⓘ
Apple Inc. Apple keyboard / Trackpad
Computer, Inc. Apple IR receiver.
Apple Inc. BRCM20702 hub.
Apple Inc. Bluetooth USB host controller.
Apple Inc. FaceTime HD camera (built-in)
Apple Inc. IPhone.
Information crush: ⓘ
Apple Inc. Thunderbolt_bus.
Goalkeeper: ⓘ
Mac App Store and identified developers
Kernel Extensions: ⓘ
/ System/Library/Extensions
com [no charge]. Cycling74.driver.Soundflower (1.5.2 - 2016-06-07) [Support]
Launch system officers: ⓘ
[loaded] 7 tasks Apple
[loading] 147 tasks Apple
[operation] 84 tasks Apple
Demons of launch system: ⓘ
[loaded] 44 tasks Apple
[loading] 153 tasks Apple
[operation] 94 tasks Apple
Launch officers: ⓘ
[no charge] com.adobe.AAM.Updater - 1.0.plist (2016-06-08) [Support]
[failure] com.adobe.ARMDCHelper.cc24aef4a1b90ed56a... plist (2016-05-23) [Support]
[operation] com.adobe.AdobeCreativeCloud.plist (2015-07-29) [Support]
[loading] com.coupons.coupond.plist (2014-02-19) [Support]
[loading] com.oracle.java.Java - Updater.plist (2014-09-10) [Support]
Launch of the demons: ⓘ
[loading] com.adobe.ARMDC.Communicator.plist (2016-05-23) [Support]
[loading] com.adobe.ARMDC.SMJobBlessHelper.plist (2016-05-23) [Support]
[loading] com.adobe.SwitchBoard.plist (2012-01-18) [Support]
[operation] com.adobe.adobeupdatedaemon.plist (2016-04-17) [Support]
[loading] com.adobe.agsservice.plist (2016-04-17) [Support]
[failure] com.adobe.fpsaud.plist (2016-04-15) [Support]
com.app4mac.CheckUpAgent.plist [failure] (2008-08-02) [Support]
[operation] com.fitbit.galileod.plist (2015-10-30) [Support]
com.makemusic.finale.Installer.cleanup.plist [no charge] (2011-12-05) [Support]
[loading] com.microsoft.office.licensing.helper.plist (2013-09-13) [Support]
[loading] com.oracle.java.Helper - Tool.plist (2014-09-10) [Support]
[loading] com.oracle.java.JavaUpdateHelper.plist (2015-08-01) [Support]
[loading] com.sibelius.sari.plist (2010-12-01) [Support]
Launch User Agents: ⓘ
[loading] com.adobe.AAM.Updater - 1.0.plist (2012-01-18) [Support]
[failure] com.adobe.ARM. [...]. plist (2011-03-03) [Support]
[loading] com.adobe.ARM. [...]. plist (2010-07-26) [Support]
[loading] com.google.keystone.agent.plist (2016-03-02) [Support]
[operation] com.spotify.webhelper.plist (2016-06-10) [Support]
User login items: ⓘ
Microsoft application to THE daemon (/ Applications/Microsoft AutoUpdate.app/Contents/MacOS/Microsoft to THE Daemon.app)
Application of system events (/ System/Library/CoreServices/System Events.app)
Dropbox application (/ Applications/Dropbox.app)
Hidden Spotify Application (/ Applications/Spotify.app)
Fitbit connect Menubar Helper Application (/ Applications/Fitbit Connect.app/Contents/MacOS/Fitbit Connect Helper.app of the menu bar)
NETGEARGenie application (/ Applications/NETGEARGenie.app)
Other applications: ⓘ
[ongoing] com.adobe.CCLibrary.8352
com.adobe.acc.AdobeCreativeCloud.73312 [loading]
[ongoing] com.adobe.acc.AdobeDesktopService.96992.31C63D4A - 84D 1-4113-A5A3-A04138ACC90B
[ongoing] com.fitbit.GalileoMenubar.156832
[ongoing] com.getdropbox.dropbox.49312
[ongoing] com.microsoft.Excel.77792
[ongoing] com.microsoft.Office365Service.83232
com.microsoft.Word.78752 [loading]
[ongoing] com.Microsoft.AutoUpdate.FBA.148832
[ongoing] org.Mozilla.Firefox.71712
[loading] 407 tasks Apple
[operation] 231 tasks Apple
Internet Plug-ins: ⓘ
DirectorShockwave: 11.6.8r638 (2012-10-04) [Support]
Default browser: 601 - SDK 10.11 (2016-05-27)
Flip4Mac WMV Plugin: 2.1.3.10 (2007-10-08) [Support]
Musicnotes: 1.19.0 (2011-08-05) [Support]
RealPlayer Plugin: Unknown (2012-08-17) [Support]
AdobeAAMDetect: 3.0.0.0 - SDK 10.9 (2016-04-17) [Support]
FlashPlayer - 10.6: 21.0.0.226 - SDK 10.6 (2016-04-21) [Support]
AdobePDFViewerNPAPI: 15.016.20045 - SDK 10.11 (2016-06-07) [Support]
Silverlight: 5.1.20513.0 - SDK 10.6 (2013-10-09) [Support]
QuickTime Plugin: 7.7.3 (2016-05-27)
Flash Player: 21.0.0.226 - SDK 10.6 (2016-04-21) obsolete! Update
iPhotoPhotocast: 7.0 (2010-07-25)
SharePointBrowserPlugin: 14.6.0 - SDK 10.6 (2016-01-12) [Support]
AdobePDFViewer: 15.016.20045 - SDK 10.11 (2016-06-07) [Support]
CouponPrinter-FireFox_v2: 5.0.3 - SDK 10.6 (2014-03-20) [Support]
Scorch: Unknown - SDK 10.2 (2013-09-21) [Support]
JavaAppletPlugin: Version of Java 8 update checking 51 (2015-08-01)
The internet user Plug-ins: ⓘ
WebEx64: 1.0 - SDK 10.6 (2013-04-27) [Support]
Stamps.com: 1.1.12 (2013-06-20) [Support]
The Safari Extensions: ⓘ
iTube Studio - iSkysoft Studio - http://www.iskysoft.com (2012-07-02)
3rd party preference panes: ⓘ
Flash Player (2016-04-15) [Support]
Flip4Mac WMV (2007-10-08) [Support]
Java (2015-08-01) [Support]
Time Machine: ⓘ
Time Machine not configured!
Top of page process CPU: ⓘ
10% Dropbox
9% WindowServer
8% kernel_task
7% adobe CEF Helper (2)
3% codesign
Top of the process of memory: ⓘ
Kernel_task 799 MB
582 MB firefox
336 MB mdworker (20)
Dropbox 229 MB
ITunes 229 MB
Information about virtual memory: ⓘ
21 MB of free RAM
7.98 GB RAM (2.57 GB being cached) used
131 MB used Swap
Diagnostic information: ⓘ
June 18, 2016, 09:16:20 AM/Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports/Adobe InDesign CC 2015_2016-06-18-091620_ .hang [deleted]
/ Applications/Adobe InDesign 2015/Adobe InDesign 2015.app/Contents/MacOS/Adobe InDesign 2015 CC CC CC
June 18, 2016, 09:16:19 /Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports/firefox_2016-06-18-091619_[redacted].hang
/Applications/Firefox.app/Contents/MacOS/Firefox
June 17, 2016, 14:15:57 ~/Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports/Adobe Flash Player install Manager_2016-06-17-141557_ [redacted] .crash
com.Adobe.flashplayer.installmanager - Applications/Utilities/Adobe Flash Player install Manager.app/Contents/MacOS/Adobe install Manager of Flash Player
June 16, 2016, 13:48:15 /Library/Logs/DiagnosticReports/firefox_2016-06-16-134815_[redacted].cpu_resour ce.diag [details]
I have no idea what you have tried, but your HARD drive is suspect. Start 4 option on the partition recovery and in the menu select disk utility. Run disk utility > first aid > repair. If the HARD disk is not repairable the disc must be replaced.
Ciao.
-
I've recently updated to El Capitan 10.11.5. Since then, my Mac is running very slowly. Help!
Hello
Much easier to troubleshoot why your Mac is slow so after upgrading of the El Capitan if you download and run EtreCheck
Then copy and paste the results in your response.
NO personal data is shared in the report.
This should give us an idea of what is causing the problem.
-
I just looked at problems with importing files from nikon D810 in LR 5.7 it pop a window saying it can't read the files to work on an imac 27 "yosemite on my mac pro running after several times he finally managed to read files and import them into LR, I never had this problem before there was a sort of update that could from cause?
What is the destination folder that the date be underneath? In the top right it says users who suggests, you try to put the photos on top of your username instead of under your username. Maybe that's the problem. So change your folder in the drop-down list at the bottom right of what it should be rather than users, and if you're going to show us the destination of your photos at least scroll through the list of folders down right so that we can see which is the white highlight.
Here is how mine looks like if I want to put my photos imported under my subfolder users - Steve - photos by date:
-
Mac Pro is not displayed after the passage of the screens
OK, so this is a strange problem but it's very annoying (at least for me). I just bought a LG Ultrawide 29 "display and connected via a HDMI cable to my Mac Pro (Home machine) and a second HDMI cable to my Macbook Pro (desktop computer). The Mac pro / Macbook pro good work with the big screen, HOWEVER, when I use my Mac pro and select the tilt of the screen to switch to the HDMI 2 connection, it works and rocking on my Macbook pro. But when I try to switch it back to HDMI 1 (Mac Pro), it comes back with a black screen and says no signal. Even if I plug the HDMI cable it does not work. I set the timer to 3 hours sleep, doesn't always help. I know he's not missing sleep because itunes can be played when I spend and still playing music throughout and continued when I try to switch back. The only way I could get is long, press the button on my Mac Pro and restart.
The only reasonable difference that I know is that the Macbook pro is running Yosemites, while my Mac Pro running Beta El Capitan. I have a feeling, this is probably the cause, but I just wanted to know if someone has solved this problem somehow.
Thank you
Hello Hemlock70,
Thank you for using communities of Apple Support.
I understand that your external screen remains completely black, with a message no signal, during the passage of the views. For assistance with this problem, please go through the steps in the link provided below.
Get help with graphical problems on external displays connected to your Mac.
Take care.
-
my computer runs very slow, what can I do?
my computer runs very slow, what can I do?
* original title - performance and security in Internet Explorer *.
Hello
Use the startup clean and other methods to try to determine the cause of and eliminate
the questions.---------------------------------------------------------------
What antivirus/antispyware/security products do you have on the machine? Be one you have NEVER
on this machine, including those you have uninstalled (they leave leftovers behind which can cause
strange problems).----------------------------------------------------
Follow these steps:
Start - type this in the search box-> find COMMAND at the top and RIGHT CLICK – RUN AS ADMIN
Enter this at the command prompt - sfc/scannow
How to analyze the log file entries that the Microsoft Windows Resource Checker (SFC.exe) program
generates in Windows Vista cbs.log
http://support.Microsoft.com/kb/928228Also run CheckDisk, so we cannot exclude as much as possible of the corruption.
How to run the check disk at startup in Vista
http://www.Vistax64.com/tutorials/67612-check-disk-Chkdsk.html==========================================
After the foregoing:
How to troubleshoot a problem by performing a clean boot in Windows Vista
http://support.Microsoft.com/kb/929135
How to troubleshoot performance issues in Windows Vista
http://support.Microsoft.com/kb/950685Optimize the performance of Microsoft Windows Vista
http://support.Microsoft.com/kb/959062
To see everything that is in charge of startup - wait a few minutes with nothing to do - then right-click
Taskbar - the Task Manager process - take a look at stored by - Services - this is a quick way
reference (if you have a small box at the bottom left - show for all users, then check that).How to check and change Vista startup programs
http://www.Vistax64.com/tutorials/79612-startup-programs-enable-disable.htmlA quick check to see that load method 2 is - using MSCONFIG then put a list of
those here.
--------------------------------------------------------------------Tools that should help you:
Process Explorer - free - find out which files, key of registry and other objects processes have opened.
What DLLs they have loaded and more. This exceptionally effective utility will show you even who has
each process.
http://TechNet.Microsoft.com/en-us/Sysinternals/bb896653.aspxAutoruns - free - see what programs are configured to start automatically when you start your system
and you log in. Autoruns also shows you the full list of registry and file locations where applications can
Configure auto-start settings.
http://TechNet.Microsoft.com/en-us/sysinternals/bb963902.aspx
Process Monitor - Free - monitor the system files, registry, process, thread and DLL real-time activity.
http://TechNet.Microsoft.com/en-us/Sysinternals/bb896645.aspxThere are many excellent free tools from Sysinternals
http://TechNet.Microsoft.com/en-us/Sysinternals/default.aspx-Free - WhatsInStartUP this utility displays the list of all applications that are loaded automatically
When Windows starts. For each request, the following information is displayed: Type of startup (registry/Startup folder), Command - Line String, the product name, Version of the file, the name of the company;
Location in the registry or the file system and more. It allows you to easily disable or remove unwanted
a program that runs in your Windows startup.
http://www.NirSoft.NET/utils/what_run_in_startup.htmlThere are many excellent free tools to NirSoft
http://www.NirSoft.NET/utils/index.htmlWindow Watcher - free - do you know what is running on your computer? Maybe not. The window
Watcher says it all, reporting of any window created by running programs, if the window
is visible or not.
http://www.KarenWare.com/PowerTools/ptwinwatch.aspMany excellent free tools and an excellent newsletter at Karenware
http://www.KarenWare.com/===========================================
Vista and Windows 7 updated drivers love then here's how update the most important.
This is my generic how updates of appropriate driver:
This utility, it is easy see which versions are loaded:
-Free - DriverView utility displays the list of all device drivers currently loaded on your system.
For each driver in the list, additional useful information is displayed: load address of the driver,
Description, version, product name, company that created the driver and more.
http://www.NirSoft.NET/utils/DriverView.htmlFor drivers, visit manufacturer of emergency system and of the manufacturer of the device that are the most common.
Control Panel - device - Graphics Manager - note the brand and complete model
your video card - double - tab of the driver - write version information. Now, click on update
Driver (this can do nothing as MS is far behind the certification of drivers) - then right-click.
Uninstall - REBOOT it will refresh the driver stack.Repeat this for network - card (NIC), Wifi network, sound, mouse, and keyboard if 3rd party
with their own software and drivers and all other main drivers that you have.Now in the system manufacturer (Dell, HP, Toshiba as examples) site (in a restaurant), peripheral
Site of the manufacturer (Realtek, Intel, Nvidia, ATI, for example) and get their latest versions. (Look for
BIOS, Chipset and software updates on the site of the manufacturer of the system here.)Download - SAVE - go to where you put them - right click - RUN AD ADMIN - REBOOT after
each installation.Always check in the Device Manager - drivers tab to be sure the version you actually install
presents itself. This is because some restore drivers before the most recent is installed (sound card drivers
in particular that) so to install a driver - reboot - check that it is installed and repeat as
necessary.Repeat to the manufacturers - BTW in the DO NOT RUN THEIR SCANNER device - check
manually by model.Look at the sites of the manufacturer for drivers - and the manufacturer of the device manually.
http://pcsupport.about.com/od/driverssupport/HT/driverdlmfgr.htmHow to install a device driver in Vista Device Manager
http://www.Vistax64.com/tutorials/193584-Device-Manager-install-driver.htmlIf you update the drivers manually, then it's a good idea to disable the facilities of driver under Windows
Updates, that leaves about Windows updates but it will not install the drivers that will be generally
older and cause problems. If updates offers a new driver and then HIDE it (right click on it), then
get new manually if you wish.How to disable automatic driver Installation in Windows Vista - drivers
http://www.AddictiveTips.com/Windows-Tips/how-to-disable-automatic-driver-installation-in-Windows-Vista/
http://TechNet.Microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc730606 (WS.10) .aspx===========================================
Refer to these discussions because many more excellent advice however don't forget to check your antivirus
programs, the main drivers and BIOS update and also solve the problems with the cleanboot method
first.Problems with the overall speed of the system and performance
http://support.Microsoft.com/GP/slow_windows_performance/en-usPerformance and Maintenance Tips
http://social.answers.Microsoft.com/forums/en-us/w7performance/thread/19e5d6c3-BF07-49ac-a2fa-6718c988f125Explorer Windows stopped working
http://social.answers.Microsoft.com/forums/en-us/w7performance/thread/6ab02526-5071-4DCC-895F-d90202bad8b3I hope this helps and happy holidays!
Rob Brown - Microsoft MVP<- profile="" -="" windows="" expert="" -="" consumer="" :="" bicycle="" -="" mark="" twain="" said="" it="">->
-
My windows 8.1 is running very slow and freezes from time to time.
My windows 8.1 is running very slow and freezes from time to time. So I ran sfc/scannow. It finds corrupted files, but could not correct. So I ran "dism / online/cleanup-image /restorehealth ' but there as well. Please help as soon as possible. Thank you!!!
Original title: find files corrupt after sfc/scannow and could not repair
Hello Akash,
Thanks for the reply.
As you said, after completing the scan found SFC, you get an error message indicating that there is corruption but was not repaired. Then, please follow the following suggestions to solve the problem.
Use the System File Checker tool to repair missing or corrupted system files
(Refer to: manually replace the corrupted file with a good copy of the file)
http://support.Microsoft.com/kb/929833/en-us
I hope this helps. Otherwise, feel free to write us again and we will be happy to help you.
-
My MacBook Pro runs very slowly. I El Captain 10.11.4 rare apps on it, most are closed while I'm on safari. My photos take a 125 gb storage capacity. If that is the question, what external hard drive is recommended? If not, what is?
Download and and publish a report of Etrecheck:
Ciao.
-
Games led by 7 Microsoft running very slow and draggy
I still have a problem to play all the games on my new computer, which is managed by Windows 7. The game runs very slow and response of the mouse and other controls are slow and draggy. Please notify.
What video card you are using as well as the model and brand of PC?
Have you updated all readers more recent? If this is not the case consult your OEM and download all the latest drivers for Win 7
MCP. MCDST. LVL 80
-
My computer hp pavilion laptop runs very slow please help
I bought a computer hp laptop pavilion g6 with i3 4 GB of ram and 1 GB graphics. It is only 9 months old and I've used it about 50 ~ 70 times alone. And now, it is very slow. I installed only 26 programs and no any program is larger than 1.5 GB but now it is running very slow and am very lag. So please help me what should I do?Open the troubleshooter of Performance
http://Windows.Microsoft.com/en-us/Windows7/open-the-performance-TroubleshooterOptimize Windows 7 for better performance
http://Windows.Microsoft.com/en-us/Windows7/optimize-Windows-7-for-better-performanceWays to improve your computer's performance
http://Windows.Microsoft.com/en-us/Windows7/ways-to-improve-your-computers-performance
Maybe you are looking for
-
Unable to access applications in iCloud desktop
When I'm on a PC I can't access Pages, Numbers, pictures or iCloud drive. I can access it fine from my Mac, but when I'm at work I need to access the Pages on a PC I could do before, but for some reason any the last time I tried on my work machine it
-
I can't read this in my windows 7 64 bit language English screenshot here please help
I can't read this in my windows 7 64 bit language English screenshot here please help Iaaaeuuee - eiiieaeo niaoeaeecediaaiiue, idaaiacia÷aiiue adult idiaeoediaaieÿe iiaaioiaee idiecaianoaa sound in Russian I know, but it looks like the Russian
-
VerticalField Manager Custom Image display and scrolling problem
I have the following code, which does a great job to display my buttons and text in my 8530. The problem I have is when I view it on another phone the image goes all the way to the bottom of the screen (for example on a 9550 sim card). When I add t
-
Configuration of blackBerry Smartphones, BB App World icon icon does not
Hello! I have BB Torch 9810 and I recently experience given my previous BB Curve 9300... Although all e-mails, contacts restered 100%, I started having problems with the 9810 BB... World Apps BB icon didn't exist in the office while I installed and r
-
Contacts of MSN Messenger of Smartphones blackBerry not sorted by name
Hi I have problems with my contacts on the messenger, that I can get it not sort by name, all names are listed at random?