Edit a copy with Lightroom adjustments

Suppose I have a PSD in my Lightroom catalog that has not been adjusted in Lightroom since it was catalogued.  When Photo-> Edit in...-> edit in Photoshop CC 2014, it seems to me that the default should be 'Edit Original'.  However, "edit a copy with Lightroom adjustments" is always selected by default.

Here's why I think that 'Edit the Original' is the default value appropriate for this case.  "Edit Original" told me that a second round of editing in Photoshop will be perfectly harmless.  When the default value is 'Edit a copy with Lightroom adjustments' my first reaction is to ask that if I proceeded to Lightroom adjustments for the file or not, to find out, I need to set up the film so I can see the badges, then 99% of the time I'll select 'modify the Original.

Two questions: (1) why do you think that Adobe has chosen this default?  (2) is there a way to change the default value for non - raw files with whom have no settings in Lightroom?


I am running 2015 CC Lightroom and Photoshop CC (2014).

On my system Windows 7 with LR CC 2015 the "Edit In" setting is the 'last used' setting (sticky). If I choose "First Edition" the next time I use "Edit in" that's what it shows. You see the same behavior?

Tags: Photoshop Lightroom

Similar Questions

  • Yesterday, I installed Photoshop CC (2014) through the creative cloud app. Now, when in Lightroom when I go to "change in" and select Photoshop CC (2014) and click on "edit copy with Lightroom adjustments", it opens Photoshop CC (2014) but my picture does

    Yesterday, I installed Photoshop CC (2014) through the creative cloud app. Now, when in Lightroom when I go to "Edit in" and select Photoshop CC (2014) and click on "edit copy with Lightroom adjustments", it opens Photoshop CC (2014) but my picture does not appear?  My picture is displayed when I click on "copy edit" or "edit original".

    How can I fix this so that I can open a photo in Lightroom WITH Lightroom adjustments? Thank you!

    My problem has been resolved by Adobe engineers. It seems that automatic resettlement carried out by sets of upgrade to win 10 everything to "run as Administrator". The simple solution, they told me was to disable this limitation and now everything works as it should.

  • Photoshop CS5/Lightroom 3 issue of integration - 'Edit copy with Lightroom adjustments' does not work

    When you click on 'Edit copy with Lightoomroom adjustments' from Lightroom, I get an error in Lightroom 3 complain that plug in Camera Raw is not up-to-date; full message below.

    "This version of Lightroom can require the Photoshop Camera Raw plugin version 6.1 for full compatibility."

    Camera Raw 4.6 version is the last version available for Photoshop CS3. If your camera raw files support has been introduced after Camera Raw 4.6, in Lightroom Photoshop integration features require Photoshop CS4 and the latest Camera Raw version 5 plug-ins.

    The version of Camera Raw-plug-in installed currently is 0.0. »

    When I click on 'Open anyway', Photoshop CS5 is launched, but he seems to have lost the context of why it opens and asks me which file I want to open (i.e. the open as a dialog box).

    "Copy edit" and "Edit Original" of Lightroom 3 works as expected and opens images in Photoshop, CS5 however.

    My installation is on Windows 7. I currently also have Lightroom 1.4 and Photoshop CS3 installed. Everything worked fine with the old configuration. I also tried the same workflow Lightroom 1.4 again just on time, which is now connected to CS5 instead of CS3. The 'Edit Copy with Lightroom adjustments"also work very well.

    Things I have tried but have not worked:

    • I did an update through the help-> Update menu and also manually downloaded the plug in Camera Raw 6.1.
    • The Photoshop preferences file blew
    • Made sure that Lightroom 3 points to Photoshop for the editor

    I think I'll try to uninstall CS3 then. Has anyone else experienced this problem?

    The usual difficulty for this and similar problems is to reinstall Photoshop CS5. Do not reinstall CS3 after CS5, otherwise it will pick up again

  • Edit a copy with lightroom adjustment has suddenly stopped working

    I used photoshop CS6 and lightroom 3.4 for quite awhile. However I can not suddenly move images from lightroom to photoshop (Ctrl + E) with the "edit a copy with lightroom adjustment".

    When I click on this option, it opens the Photoshop. But does not open the image. However, the other two options "edit a copy" and "Original Edition" works very well.

    Also when I add as another external editor photoshop, it works very well. But as you all are aware of this create another copy of the image.

    What I've done

    I checked the path of applications for photoshop and it was OK.

    I uninstalled lightroom and reinstalled.

    JosephPatrick wrote:

    I just started having the same problem. When I edit a photo in Ps from Lr. The dialog box is not started, and if I edited in LR it takes adjustments and opens to the PS. I have Lr cc v2015.5.1 camera raw 9.5.1. I have reset all warning dialog boxes. Weird. I suspect that there is a bug. Any ideas?

    Please start your own thread. Since you have LR CC 2015.5.1 you also PS CC 2015.1.2.

    What you see is normal. When you select Edit in Photoshop LR and PS use the same version of ACR so no dialog is necessary. Your RAW image opens in PS with all the LR settings included as a type of RAW file waiting to be saved as all that you have selected the type of file in External Editor preferences of LR, PSD or TIF section. The only time you get this dialog window is if ACR versions do not match. LR uses a version more recent ACR uses the PS version you have installed.

  • LR 3.2. Can't edit in PS with LR adjustments?

    When I select 'Edit in PS4' it has no option to edit with LR adjustments, & even if I chose to edit them as TIFF, it opens as a CR2 file without any adjustment.

    You must configure Photoshop as a secondary Editor. Then Lightroom will automatically using the selected format. Otherwise, it will send the raw file directly with the instructions for Photoshop. It will make the adjustments he knows how, but since LR 3 are only fully compatible with CS5, it doesn't make it the same. Lightroom expected offer to make it for you as it has done in previous times, there was a mismatch of version, but for some reason it isn't. I take it as a bug.

  • LR 5.6 bug - edit a copy w LR adjustments does not account for Radial filters

    When I use this option to edit in PS CS6, the image that opens to the PS does not contain the Radial filter settings I've done.  This seems to be a bug.

    What camera raw you have installed in the PS - CS6, ACR 8.6 or something else?  And when the file arrives in PS, in the title bar, he says it's always a raw file or a TIF or PSD?

  • Editing in photoshop from lightroom photo 4

    In the case of lightroom 4, selecting a photo and choose Edit in photoshop, sometimes a dialog box opens asking if I want to open original or copy with lightroom edits and sometimes it just opened in photoshop without the options. Anyone know why this is

    Hello!

    If you open a non - raw such as TIFF, PSD or Jpeg image in Lightroom, you will offer the open dialog box asking "edit a copy with lightroom adjustments", "edit a copy" or "Edit original".

    If you open a raw image with the option of additional external editor, the only available option is to edit a copy pixel-rendering using Lightroom adjustment: "edit a copy with lightroom adjustments.

    To learn more on the subject, please read:

    http://www.adobepress.com/articles/article.asp?p=1930488

    Please post back with other questions.

    Janelle

  • Why my Photoshop removed the Raw file directly from Lightroom instead of asking me if I want to edit a copy?

    I used to get a pop up every time I tried to retouch a photo in PS asking if I wanted to do it on a copy with Lightroom adjustments and he created me a TIFF file, but now it takes just the RAW file. How can I get it back?

    I use the terrible PS CC 2015 and LR CC2015

    Hi Manolo,

    If you right click on the Jpeg Image in Lightroom and don't edit it in Photoshop, which gives you this opportunity.

    If you reference the above option in the screenshot, you receive only when edit you a Raw image from Lightroom to Photoshop format.

    Kind regards

    ~ Mohit

  • photo with LR adjustments cannot be changed in PES

    If in LR, I hit CTRL-E, I get 3 options for editing. I edit in PSE14 if I select 'modify a copy of the original.  If I select "edit a copy with LR adjustments", PSE14 opens a copy, but none of the features is available (the cursor is a circle with a slash through it).  This is true for open them as copies. TIFF or. PSD (settings in the preferences).  what I am doing wrong?

    In Lightroom, go to:

    Edit > preferences > external edit (tab)

    You can have the files configurΘ to dΘmarrer in 16 bits. Change the settings to 8 bits as there is limited functionality in the items to edit 16-bit files.

  • Help... I have Adobe cc with Lightroom installed on my macbook and iMac and photos on an external drive... but

    I edited several photos with lightroom and this external hard drive via my macbook pro. When I unplug my external drive and connect to my iMac and import a folder (no copy and move), none of my edits are here! or the sides. I can see all the photos of perfectly fine, but how do I get my cc in lightroom on my iMac to see my photos as they have been published on my instance mackook of cc in lightroom? They are certainly on the drive? I don't want to put this folder of images into space cloud that I have not the download speed or space provided. Any help appreciated.

    The changes are saved in the catalog, not for pictures.

    So to see the changes on both computers, you will need to keep the file containing the LR catalog and previews on the external hard drive.

    Use the Finder to copy this folder since the Macbook pro hard disk external. It is usually located inside the images folder or similar.

    Now make sure you always open the catalog from the external drive. To avoid confusion you can rename the catalog if you like, you then have to rename the folder seen accordingly. Make sure you do it with closed Lightroom. You can launch LR by double-clicking the file catalog.

  • A stand-alone problem with Lightroom 6 passing files to edit in Photoshop CS6 independent

    With Lightroom 6 opened in 'Library' mode and display the images in the display of the grid, I select an image and right-click on it and choose the offered menu "Edit in > edit in Photoshop CS6»

    I get no options as the original or original with Lightroom alterations etc., he just goes ahead and open Photoshop, but fails to transmit the image and I find myself with an open Photoshop but not picture.

    Suggestions as to how could be remedied this problem.

    Thanks, Stephen

    Solve the problem by the following steps:

    1 launched Photoshop third-party plugins to jump (with SHIFT key during launch)

    2A tried to open an image from Lightroom to Photoshop > open very well

    3. copy all the plugins from the location next to the desktop and removed from its current location.

    4 put them one by one back to the original location of the office and tried to open the Lightproom image to Photoshop at the same time to find the plugin that was defective.

    5 development and coral as the defective one, installed them only in Lightroom and removed from Photohsop

    ~ Sarika

  • I installed my own copy of Lightroom 5 to 5.7. Now all files I try to develop gives me a message "there was an error working with this photo. What should I do?

    I installed my own copy of Lightroom 5 to 5.7. Now all files I try to develop gives me a message "there was an error working with this photo. What should I do?

    Thanks Tanuj

    My fault. I restarted my computer and everything is still OK

    Thanks again

    Paul

  • How can I register my copy of Lightroom 5.7 with the serial number that I bought? Information system currently lists the type of license as "creative cloud."

    How can I register my copy of Lightroom 5.7 with the serial number that I bought? Information system currently lists the type of license as "creative cloud."

    I downloaded 5.7.1, he asked for a serial number, and now everything is OK. Thanks for the help.

  • I work with Lightroom 3 and want to use photoshop element 8 to edit photos.

    I work with Lightroom 3 and want to use photoshop element 8 to edit photos.  Problem in Lightroom – photo tab there is no option "EDIT IN".  What should I do?

    Hi ssft,

    Follow the steps in the article to add an external editor in Lightroom Photoshop Elements 8 preferences:

    Adobe Photoshop Lightroom Help | Editing photos Lightroom in Photoshop or Photoshop Elements

  • I lost 5 Lightroom bought in Dec 2014 and want to download another copy with a serial number.  It is not available on the site of Adobe Web and Im not interested in Lightroom CC.  Can you direct me to an appropriate site? Thanks Frank

    I lost 5 Lightroom bought in Dec 2014 and want to download another copy with a serial number.  It is not available on the site of Adobe Web and Im not interested in Lightroom CC.  Can you direct me to an appropriate site? Thanks Frank

    Lightroom - all versions

    Windows

    http://www.Adobe.com/support/downloads/product.jsp?product=113&platform=Windows

    Mac

    http://www.Adobe.com/support/downloads/product.jsp?product=113&platform=Macintosh

Maybe you are looking for

  • Do not reach a message from code keychain

    I am meshal I waited a message code Keychain is not reached for the phone number *. Help, please < personal information under the direction of the host >

  • Are my system or RAM faulty graphics card RAM? MacBook Pro crashes several times a day.

    Any time I see pictures, usually after several system crashes and restarts automatically. Because that's when I'm viewing images, it leads me to believe the graphics card or RAM is a failure. System is about 6 years old now. Here are the accident rep

  • upgrade the hard drive internal 1 TB SSHD to the Macbook pro (pro mid-2010)

    OS X El Capitan (10.11.3) MBP 13-inch, mid 2010 2.4 GHz Intel Core 2 Duo RAM: 8 GB I just bought this Seagate 1 TB SATA SSHD 54. Is it possible that I can clone the old hard drive (250 MB) on this new disc hard safely? A video supposed to be removing

  • Update Windows Vista 0xc8000222 error code

    original title: Vista error 0xc8000222 code I just installed a new hard drive and reinstalled vista and sp 1 & 2 but when I try to run the update or install fix powershell I get the 0xc8000222 error code. Any ideas?

  • Drive__XP SP3.5__Low hard disk space

    Hello My 60 GB hard drive in my netbook is almost full, even if I deleted all personal objects and performs the basic package it came with (XP, Microsoft Works). I get the disk space warning is very low, and I want to free up space on the disk if pos