recommendation of Oracle asmlib or raw for 11g ASM

looking for best practice note on this subject for different OS such as linux, Solaris and windows? and how to configure?

DBA2008 wrote:
looking for best practices note on this subject for different OS like linux, Solaris & windows? & How to configure?

You're confused raw (raw devices) with "raw + +" (block devices for raw character devices)...

To explain...

All devices are 'rough' - even your 'C: drive ' traditional... until what it is mounted by a driver that provides access "cooked the file system.

Oracle ASM works directly with these raw devices - it must NOT be mounted by a file system driver (ASM can not use it because the camera is locked/used by this other driver). And the raw device does NOT contain a file system (ASM will open this device and destroy).

So what of the question that "raw is obsolete? It is a device driver very specific on Unix/Linux allowing a character (raw) device be used as a (raw) blocking the device. Why?

Because on older kernels do not use the direct i/o (RAW) only on (raw) and character devices, block devices. This crude device driver linked a block on a character device device, allowing direct use e/s. And direct i/o is what s/w like file systems of RDBMS and want ASM dealing with raw as oppose to the cooking devices.

So there is no such notion as ' raw devices versus AsmLib + + ". This is absurd.

AsmLib is a kernel driver that provides a layer of management for raw devices logical device. The same type of s/w delivered by default under Linux and is called Multipath.

EMC has their own patented kernel called Powerpath driver which covers essentially the same game featured.

So to use the raw devices is the standard and the standard with the ASM. The storage array or LUN from the server will be seen by the kernel of the server database as scsi devices. These devices must be put at the disposal of the DSO. There are issues such as multiple I/O paths to the SAN to address. Issues such as consistency in device name. Issues such as ownership of the device and permissions. Etc.

AsmLib can be used at this address. Is it recommended? Not really because on Linux Multipath is designed to do this work. And she does very well on the clusters of 1000 + node connected to without very seriously. He does what AsmLib and better - with the exception of being able to format a device of ASM with a label header ASM (made by ASM itself anyway to a new disk to a disk group).

So yes, there's Metalink/MoS notes that proclaim the '+' goodness + AsmLib. But this isn't a prerequisite. It is not recommended by Oracle to use as a replacement for Multipath (none of the best docs of practical Oracle I said that).

Don't forget that AsmLib is a layer of extra kernel drivers that must be loaded and configured. I don't see the use of myself and we don't use AsmLib on any of our RAC clusters. Multipath is used and it does the job and does it well.

Tags: Database

Similar Questions

  • Oracle ORA-01034 unavailable for 11g R2 xe

    I get the following error

    Oracle not available ORA-01034
    ORA-27101 shared memory realm does not exist
    process ID: 0
    session id: 0 serial No.: 0

    In the paper, I get the same

    Message not found 51; No product message file = RDBMS, installation = ORADIM

    My Tnsnames.ora is

    XE =
    (DESCRIPTION =
    (ADDRESS = (PROTOCOL = TCP) (HOST = siva-ae2ba51)(PORT = 1521))
    (CONNECT_DATA =
    (SERVER = DEDICATED)
    (SERVICE_NAME = XE)
    )
    )

    EXTPROC_CONNECTION_DATA =
    (DESCRIPTION =
    (ADDRESS_LIST =
    (ADDRESS = (PROTOCOL = CIP)(KEY = EXTPROC1))
    )
    (CONNECT_DATA =
    (SID = PLSExtProc)
    (PRESENTATION = RO)
    )
    )

    ORACLR_CONNECTION_DATA =
    (DESCRIPTION =
    (ADDRESS_LIST =
    (ADDRESS = (PROTOCOL = CIP)(KEY = EXTPROC1))
    )
    (CONNECT_DATA =
    (SID = CLRExtProc)
    (PRESENTATION = RO)
    )
    )

    Listener.ora
    =============

    SID_LIST_LISTENER =
    (SID_LIST =
    (SID_DESC =
    (SID_NAME = PLSExtProc)
    (ORACLE_HOME = F:\oraclexe\app\oracle\product\11.2.0\server)
    (= Extproc PROGRAM)
    )
    (SID_DESC =
    (SID_NAME = CLRExtProc)
    (ORACLE_HOME = F:\oraclexe\app\oracle\product\11.2.0\server)
    (= Extproc PROGRAM)
    )
    )

    LISTENER =
    (DESCRIPTION_LIST =
    (DESCRIPTION =
    (ADDRESS = (PROTOCOL = CIP)(KEY = EXTPROC1))
    (ADDRESS = (PROTOCOL = TCP) (HOST = siva-ae2ba51)(PORT = 1521))
    )
    )

    DEFAULT_SERVICE_LISTENER = (XE)

    can you get it someone pls suggest me what I do for this

    Published by: Jean Jacques on September 26, 2011 05:36

    Lina says:
    I get the following error

    Oracle not available ORA-01034

    Is it a new installation, so that the instance has never been available earlier?

    If this is the case, you might as well just remove and start again rather than trying to solve an installation failure.

    What is the platform/os, Windows? Edition, version, etc.

    Message not found 51; No product message file = RDBMS, installation = ORADIM

    Dim - 51 simply means that this instance has been created successfully, so not really mistake in my opinion.

  • 11g ASM the database using 10g will be the new features in 11g ASM available?

    We are on 10.2.0.3 database without ASM version. Convert now to 11g ASM.

    Can I take advatage of new features in 11g ASM with 10g RDBMS Database? If any limitation so that is advatge for me to go to 11g ASM on 10g RDBMS, as appropriate?

    Thank you
    Verdier

    Hello

    I was living benefits ASM 11 g as (ACFS, ADVM, instant, IIP of Placement Intelligent Data). I could be > to use one of these if my RDBMS is 10g?

    Here: [features enabled by disk group attribute compatibility settings | http://download.oracle.com/docs/cd/E11882_01/server.112/e10500/asmdiskgrps.htm#CHDBCHIH] there is a table with what is or is not possible to use depending on your configuration.

    The specific advantages/disadvantages if we opt for 11g ASM for 10g RDBMS DB? We are planing to implement this > so any information / documentary links will be appreciated.

    The main advantage is that a single instance of the ASM will be able to support different customer RDBMS and the main disadvantage is that not all ASM new feautures will be supported for disk groups that are defined for reduce the compatibility properties.

    It will be useful,
    Cerreia

  • A-team - MAF Persistence Framework - is available for the MAF and it is an approach recommended by Oracle for Application Data Sync?

    Hi OTN community.

    My query is on Oracle team Persistence framework (http://www.ateam-oracle.com/going-mobile-with-adf-implementing-data-caching-and-syncing-for-working-offline/).

    It is available for the MAF and it is an approach recommended by Oracle for the implementation of data synchronization?

    Can anyone please share their experience using this extension.

    We are currently reviewing the best approach for the implementation of data synchronization.

    Best regards

    Deepak

    See: persistence of the MAF Oracle for SQLite

    Frank

  • Oracle SOA Suite install for EBS R12.2.3

    I use the following Oracle Support document trying to get SOAP based web services for my install R12.2.3 Vision.

    Installation of Oracle E-Business Suite integrated SOA Gateway, version 12.2 (Doc ID 1311068.1()

    The first step is to install on SOA, if I can have more SOA running on the same VM as my app server.

    The DB and the application server are boxes VM with 12 GB RAM and 400 GB of space.

    Will be the RAM problem become if services SOA and Apps work together?

    Or will it be an idea that is sure to have a box of seperateVM for the rest of the SOA

    Thank you

    Rohit

    Rohit,

    As shown in the docs--> install Oracle SOA Suite 11 g (11.1.1.7.0) (recommended) or Oracle SOA Suite 11 g (11.1.1.6.0) running on the server, WebLogic 11 g (10.3.6) on a separate Oracle WebLogic Server.

    Thank you

    Hussein

  • The Oracle ASMLib driver initialization: FAILURE

    Hello guys,.

    You need help. I don't understand this problem. Oracleasm don't load.

    Oracle version: 11.2.0.3

    Version of the Linux kernel: Linux xxx.com 2.6.18 - 371.4.1.el5 #1 SMP Wed Jan 8 18:42:00 GMT 2014 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

    ] status /etc/init.d/oracleasm #.

    Check if the DSO is loaded: no

    Check if/dev/oracleasm is mounted: no

    ------------------------------------------------------------------------

    Configure /etc/init.d/oracleasm #.

    Configuring the Oracle ASM Library driver.

    This sets up the properties on the startup of the Oracle ASM library

    pilot.  The following questions will determine whether the driver is

    load on startup and it will have permissions.  The current values

    appears between square brackets ("[]").  Hitting < ENTER > without having to type a

    response will keep this current value.  CTRL-C will stop.

    User by default to the owner of the [oracle] driver interface: oracle

    Group defaults to the owner of the [asmdba] driver interface: asmdba

    Start Oracle ASM Library driver at startup (y/n) [y]: y

    Scan of Oracle ASM disks at startup (y/n) [y]: y

    Driver configuration Oracle ASM library of writing: fact

    The Oracle ASMLib driver initialization: [FAILURE]

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------

    I downloaded the correct asm library packages.

    uname - a

    Linux hostname 2.6.18 - 371.4.1.el5 #1 SMP Wed Jan 8 18:42:00 GMT 2014 x86_64 x86_64 x86_64 GNU/Linux

    RPM - qa | grep oracleasm

    oracleasm - 2.6.18 - 371.4.1.el5 - 2.0.5 - 1.el5

    oracleasmlib - 2.0.4 - 1.el5

    oracleasm-support - 2.1.8 - 1.el5

    SELINUX is disabled.

    / var/log/oraleasm

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Reload from disk partitions: fact

    Cleaning up stale ASM disks...

    ASM disks scanning system...

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-0 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-0 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-0 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-0 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-1 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-1 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-1 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-1 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-2 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-2 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-2 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-2 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-3 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-3 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-3 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-3 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-4 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-4 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-4 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-4 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-5 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-5 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-5 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-5 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-75 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-75 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-75 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-75 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-76 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-76 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-76 ': no such file or directory

    oracleasm-read-label: could not open device ' / dev/dm-76 ': no such file or directory

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Load the module "oracleasm": failed

    Could not load module 'oracleasm.

    Can someone help me understand what I missed.

    Kind regards

    Ashish

    Hey Vandana,

    Leave was correct, he had some problems with the packages that I downloaded earlier. I downloaded again and this way it is resolved. See below.

    The only difference is in the size of RPM. First of all, I downloaded below:

    Name: oracleasmlib relocations: (not transferable)

    Version: 2.0.4 vendor: Oracle Corporation

    Release date: 1.el5 Build Date: Wednesday, March 18, 2009 03:27:43 CEST

    Install Date: Thursday, February 13, 2014 06:52:06 AM IS      Host of generation: ca - build23.us.oracle.com

    Group: System environment/Kernel Source RPM: 2.0.4 - oracleasmlib - 1.el5.src.rpm

    Size: 21792 License: Oracle Corporation

    Signature: DSA/SHA1, Thursday, December 3, 2009 03:07:19 pm, Key ID 66ced3de1e5e0159

    Packager: Joel Becker [email protected]>

    URL: http://oss.oracle.com/

    Summary: The Oracle Automatic Storage Management userspace code library.

    Description:

    The library of user Oracle for Oracle Automatic Storage Management space

    Now, I installed this and problem solved.

    Name: oracleasmlib relocations: (not transferable)

    Version: 2.0.4 vendor: Oracle Corporation

    Release date: 1.el5 Build Date: Wednesday, March 18, 2009 03:25:42 CEST

    Install Date: Friday, February 14, 2014 08:13:05 CEST      Host of generation: ca - build24.us.oracle.com

    Group: System environment/Kernel Source RPM: 2.0.4 - oracleasmlib - 1.el5.src.rpm

    Size: 25672 License: Oracle Corporation

    Signature: DSA/SHA1, Thursday, December 3, 2009 03:07:19 pm, Key ID 66ced3de1e5e0159

    Packager: Joel Becker [email protected]>

    URL: http://oss.oracle.com/

    Summary: The Oracle Automatic Storage Management userspace code library.

    Description:

    The library of user Oracle for Oracle Automatic Storage Management space

    Looks like he had a problem with the download of packages because the size varies. in any case thanks a lot.

    Kind regards
    Ashish Francis

  • The Oracle database is free for individuals?

    Is the Oracle database free for private developers, just test the database, or what I personally contact them in order to pay them? Only, I went to the page of download of Oracle and downloaded 2 pcs. Installation of 1 GB, installed files database on my Windows 7 computer and then started using it.

    Have you paid attention to the license agreement you agreed before downloading software? Restrictions on use are clearly stated.

    Oracle Technology Network Developer for Oracle Database 11g Express Edition license terms

    The limits for 11g XE are also documented-

    Oracle & reg; Database Express Edition

    Oracle & reg; Database Express Edition

    HTH
    Srini

  • Problem creating ASM Oracle ASMLib driver initialization: failure

    Hello

    OEL 5.6 64 bit
    DB 11 GR 2 64-bit
    [root@rac-1 ASM]# rpm -qa | grep ora
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5xen-2.0.5-1.el5
    libtheora-1.0alpha7-1
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5debug-2.0.5-1.el5
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5-2.0.5-1.el5
    oracle-logos-4.9.17-10
    oracle-validated-1.1.0-7.el5
    oraclelinux-release-5-6.0.1
    oracleasm-support-2.1.4-1.el5
    [root@rac-1 ASM]# rpm -qa | grep asm
    nasm-0.98.39-3.2.2
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5xen-2.0.5-1.el5
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5debug-2.0.5-1.el5
    oracleasm-2.6.18-164.el5-2.0.5-1.el5
    oracleasm-support-2.1.4-1.el5
    [root@rac-1 ASM]#
    [root@rac-1 ASM]# oracleasm configure
    ORACLEASM_ENABLED=true
    ORACLEASM_UID=oracle
    ORACLEASM_GID=asmadmin
    ORACLEASM_SCANBOOT=true
    ORACLEASM_SCANORDER=""
    ORACLEASM_SCANEXCLUDE=""
    
    
    [root@rac-1 ASM]# service oracleasm restart
    Dropping Oracle ASMLib disks:                              [  OK  ]
    Shutting down the Oracle ASMLib driver:                    [  OK  ]
    Initializing the Oracle ASMLib driver:                     [FAILED]
    [root@rac-1 ASM]#
    can anyone help?

    You may confuse the package with oracleasm oracleasmlib. The oracleasm package contains only the kernel driver, which is included in the unbreakable Oracle Enterprise core and does not need to be installed. If I remember correctly, OEL 5.6 installed the kernel default UEK.

    The oracleasm-support and oracelasmlib packages, however, are still necessary. If you have not paid to the LSN network access you can install the rpm oracleasm-taking in charge of the public yum repository for Oracle (http://public-yum.oracle.com/). Use of yum is easy and will also solve package dependency issues.

    To install oracleasmlib, you can try:
    RPM - ivh "http://download.oracle.com/otn_software/asmlib/oracleasmlib-2.0.4-1.el5.x86_64.rpm."

  • the differences between Oracle Discoverer 10 g and 11g.

    We would like to know if there are differences between Oracle Discoverer 10 g and 11g and problems with 10 g that are overcome in 11 g.


    Please make us aware of any background to 11g over 10g.


    apps version 11.5.10.2

    Concerning

    Please visit these links for the list of new features, bug fixes, certification and installation of discoverer 11g on 11i instance.

    Discoverer 11.1.1.4 certified with E - Business Suite
    http://blogs.Oracle.com/stevenChan/2011/02/discoverer_11114_ebs.html

    EBS Sysadmin Primer: Oracle BI discoverer 11 GR 1 material
    http://blogs.Oracle.com/stevenChan/2010/08/discoverer_11gr1_primer.html

    Discoverer of Oracle Business Intelligence 11g
    http://www.Oracle.com/technetwork/developer-tools/discoverer/Overview/index.html

    Oracle Business Intelligence 11g Discoverer documentation
    http://www.Oracle.com/technetwork/developer-tools/discoverer/documentation/index.html

    Thank you
    Hussein

  • Looking for 11g R2 RAC traning in NYC

    I'm looking for 11g R2 RAC traning in new york or new jersey.

    If one is teaching please answer.

    Thank you

    http://education.Oracle.com/pls/web_prod-PLQ-dad/db_pages.getCourseDesc?DC=D50102GC20&p_org_id=1001&lang=us

    http://education.Oracle.com/pls/web_prod-PLQ-dad/db_pages.getCourseDesc?DC=D50079GC20&p_org_id=1001&lang=us

  • RAW for PANASONIC DMC-FZ100 format?

    is raw for PANASONIC DMC-FZ100 really format

    supported? I have version 1.5 (6.19 brute) and I'm

    not able to change on the app.

    Yes, it is - see Digital camera RAW formats supported by OS X El Capitan - Apple Support

    What is the problem? What happens exactly?

    LN

  • RAW for DV7T-6100 sata driver

    I am looking for the raw for the DV7T-6100 .ini files and can not find them anywhere. I am trying to install Win 7 on this system and it comes up with "no cd/dvd device driver installed etc etc which really means I need drivers SATA on my Win 7 install Flash drive." Where can I find these drivers? the .exe will work of course (except if im missing something)

    Thanks in advance for any help!

    Hello:

    Try this...

    Download the drivers from this link below (first or second file listed - 32 or 64 bit depending on the case).

    https://Downloadcenter.Intel.com/Detail_Desc.aspx?AGR=Y&ProdId=2101&DwnldID=23060&keyword=Intel+RAPI...

    Extract the files on a usb flash drive.

    With the flash player and the installation of W7 media connected to the computer, boot from the installation of W7 media.

    After selecting the install now option, select the training - Advanced menu, Options and select the option load a driver.

    You should now see the storage driver files listed.

    If you check the box, it only includes the compatible driver.

    Follow the prompts and hopefully, W7 should install.

  • Error: Dragon Naturally Speaking seems to work in Compatibility Mode Windows, which can lead to errors. We recommend to disable the compatibility mode for the program natspeak

    Original title: Dragon Naturally Speaking will not charge. He was working. I have time. The only thing different is my 10 3 demo of windows expiredeinstalled

    Remember - this is a public forum so never post private information such as numbers of mail or telephone!

    Ideas:

    • Dragon Naturally Speaking does not load. He was working. I have time. The only thing different is my demo windows 10 expiredeinstalled 3 programs you have problems with
    • Error messages Dragon Naturally Speaking seems to work in Compatibility Mode Windows, which can lead to errors. We recommend to disable the compatibility mode for the program natspeak
    • Recent changes to your computer
    • What you have already tried to solve the problem I find no windows compatibility mode. I do not know how

    Hi jrskona,

    1. don't you make changes before the show?

    Try the following steps to disable the compatibility mode.
    a. Locate the launch of Dragon NaturallySpeaking file, right-click on it and click Properties.
    b. click on the Compatibility tab.
    c. in compatibility mode, uncheck the box "run this program in compatibility mode for".
    d. click ok to apply the changes.
    e. check if the problem persists.

    If the problem persists, then contact the program vendor support team:see Dragon NaturallySpeaking support

    Visit our Microsoft answers feedback Forum and let us know what you think.

  • That means recommended recommended for an ASM diskgroup to maintain production database?

    Dear Experts,

    That means recommended recommended for an ASM diskgroup to maintain production database?

    + DATA

    to keep the redo log groups redo1a, redo2a, redo3a with 3 members = redo1b, redo2b, redo3b, redo1c, redo2c, redo3c

    to organize 3 controlfiles

    organize storage of data files

    to keep the index tablespaces

    How many disk (as a point of reference)

    + FRA

    Where to place archivelogs

    Thanks in advance,

    Kind regards

    IVW

    Salvation;

    A good practice is:

    + DATA holds:

    • Redo log files, Member 1.
    • Control file.
    • Data files.

    + FRA holds:

    • Redo log files, Member of the 2.
    • Control file
    • Backup of files: archived redo logs, control automatic file backups, spills auto backups, copies, backup sets, flashback logs.

    This is the distribution of files most used; but always distribution will depend on the size of your database and how do you set up your database. Remember that you need to know how your database works. As Aman said in another post, distribution of files depends on how many disk groups you can have, depending on the speed of the disc.

    Kind regards.

    Willy

  • Oracle Application Management Pack for Oracle E-Business Suite Guide 12.1.0.4.0?

    Hello fellow pioneers OEM.

    I am trying to locate the Oracle Application Management Pack for Oracle E-Business Suite Guide 12.1.0.4.0


    I have a beautiful SR but still no answer on that of the analyst. Thank you.

    DA

    Currently the latest version of MPA is 12.1.0.3.0

Maybe you are looking for

  • I can't get iOS 9.3.2 on my iPhone 5 s

    MY 5s iPhone can't get to 9.3.2 software update

  • Samsung Blue Ray does not connect to internet, but being of other devices.

    I used this Blue Ray Samsung drive with this router for over a year without problems. A few days ago I set up parental controls, by downloading the Netgear Genie app on my PC from Windows desktop, on the router, and now Blue Ray does not connect to t

  • Sansa Connect User Guide

    Hello, I am fairly rudimentary and just bought two Sansa Connect for a very good price in a white box.  The box contained no any Quick Start Guide or user manual.  The messages that I found in this forum about the User Guide lead to links that no lon

  • restore multiple system files from Recycle Bin by using the command line

    Hello world I ' v done gone wasted with this one I downloaded a third party software to delet all files duplicate on my laptop unfortunitly I completely forgot I had put all the files in the files of system including visible on partion 1 running wind

  • Forcing BrowserFields to fill the screen; JRE BB 6.0.0

    Hello I asked this in the forums of Java before and am advice ask here, because you mustve solved this issue already. Well, said the title actually all this, how I achieve this without using fixed sizes in the content that I'm loading into the Browse