Security IOS vs PIX Firewall / ASA

Could someone point me to some docs on cisco.com in comparing the use of an IOS on a secure router & using a cisco firewall? I want to use a SRI w/fix ios if possible but don't know if I can lock the outside of the network as well as I could with a pix or asa, so I want to make sure I'm doing everything I can and do the right thing. Any help is greatly appreciated.

Hello

There is a discussion in this forum on this topic; Check "Firewalling: PIX vs IOS Firewall" last conversation was released January 10, 2006. Let me know then if it helps.

Rgrds,

Haitham

Tags: Cisco Security

Similar Questions

  • How to monitor connections dropped and rejected on the PIX Firewall / ASA?

    I need to monitor the SNMP OID of the connections dropped and rejected on the PIX and ASA firewalls. Is this possible?

    If this is the case, what SNMP OID should I monitor?

    Syslogs and Netflow (introduced in version 8.2) are your options.

    No MIB can give you the numbers of conn.

    PK

  • PIX firewall Security Guide

    Hi guys, I noticed that there is a document on the setting of the Cisco routers on cisco.com

    Is there than a best practices similar document type for Secure PIX firewall? or even a general firewall best practices guides?

    I searched, but did not really find anything. Any help would be great!

    Hi Nathan,

    So far, there is no specific doc, but you can get the idea of documentation PIX / ASA itself. This is probably due to the nature 'trust' of the firewall itself (everybody knows that it was not 100% sure).

    Anyway, there is a document on "Best practices of firewall" at http://www.principlelogic.com.

    Others are:

    http://www.Security.FSU.edu/firewall.cfm

    http://SearchSecurity.TechTarget.com/originalContent/0, 289142, sid14_gci838230, 00.html

    Personally, I think the recommendations are very good and can be applied generally to fix most of the firewall products.

    I hope this helps.

    Rgds,

    AK

    WARNING: -.

    The post above is not intended to promote the services/tools/products on behalf of a person or organizations. This is simply about & information sharing.

  • PIX firewall software

    Hi guys,.

    I am looking to download IOS ver 4,0000 for PIX 515E, but can't seem to find anywhere in the downloads/security section. The only version they have is 8.0.4.

    Anyone know where I could find all earlier versions?

    Thank you very much

    Elena

    Elena, when you go to download box, choose any version 8.0, then window right side you will see a text saying previous software release click on this hyperlink and it will take you to all versions including 7.x

    http://tools.cisco.com/support/downloads/go/ImageList.x?relVer=8.0.4&mdfid=277072390&sftType=PIX+Firewall+Software&optPlat=&nodecount=2&edesignator=ED&modelName=Cisco+PIX+515E+Security+Appliance&treeMdfId=268438162&treeName=Security&modifmdfid=&imname=&hybrid=Y&imst=N&lr=Y

    but here's the direct link

    http://www.Cisco.com/cgi-bin/tablebuild.pl/PIX

    Concerning

  • PIX firewall Image issue

    Hello

    I'm without a firewall PIX 7.0 to 6.3 decommissioning. I faced the problem during the restart of the PIX.

    The error given below,

    Start the first image in flash

    Image must be at least 7-0-0-0 error in the flash file: / pix635.bin

    No bootable Flash image. Please download an image from a network server

    in monitor mode

    CISCO PIX FIREWALL SYSTEMS

    BIOS version shipped 4.3.207 01/02/02 16:12:22.73

    Compiled by Manu

    128 MB OF RAM

    Did you follow the exact downgrade procedure indicated on this link... you point the image as shown 6.3.x

    downgrade tftp://tftpserverip/pix63x.bin

    PIX downgrade procedure 7.x to 6.3.x

    http://www.Cisco.com/en/us/docs/security/ASA/asa70/pix_upgrade/upgrade/guide/pixupgrd.html#wp1810347

    in any case, you can always redownload the 6.3.5 new code in monitor mode.

    http://www.Cisco.com/en/us/products/HW/vpndevc/ps2030/products_tech_note09186a0080094a5d.shtml#upbootormon

    Let us know how it works.

    Rgds

    Jorge

  • Access list ID # on a PIX firewall

    Is anyone know what of the identifier access list on a pix firewall?

    Standard IOS = 1-99

    Extended IOS is 100-199.

    SW = PIX?

    There is no "limit" by Word to say in the Pix. These limits are in IOS because they define what 'type' of acl, it's IE APPLETALK, IPX, IP etc etc. Pix IP is therefore not necessary for this type of identification.

    access-list 100000000000000; 1 items

    allow line of the access list 1 100000000000000 ip any a (hitcnt = 0)

    Jason

  • PIX and ASA static, dynamic and RA VPN does not

    Hello

    I am facing a very interesting problem between a PIX 515 and an ASA 5510.

    The PIX is in HQ and has several dynamic VPN connections (around 130) and IPsec vpn remote works very well. I had to add a PIX to ASA L2L VPN static and it does not work as it is supposed to be. The ASA 5510, at the remote end, connects and rest for a small period of time, however, all other VPN connections stop working.

    The most interesting thing is that ASA is associated with the dynamic map and not the static map that I created (check by sh crypto ipsec his counterpart x.x.x.x). However, if I make any changes in the ACL 'ACL-Remote' it affects the tunnel between the PIX and ASA.

    Someone saw something like that?

    Here is more detailed information:

    HQ - IOS 8.0 (3) - PIX 515

    ASA 5510 - IOS 7.2 (3) - remote provider

    Several Huawei and Cisco routers dynamically connected via ADSL

    Several users remote access IPsec

    A VPN site-to site static between PIX and ASA - does not.

    Here is the config on the PIX:

    Crypto ipsec transform-set ESP-3DES-ESP-SHA-HMAC-IPSec esp-3des esp-sha-hmac

    Dyn - VPN game 100 Dynamics-card crypto transform-set ESP-3DES-ESP-SHA-HMAC-IPSec

    Crypto dynamic-map Dyn - VPN 100 the value reverse-road

    VPN - card 30 crypto card matches the ACL address / remote

    card crypto VPN-card 30 peers set 20 x. XX. XX. XX

    card crypto VPN-card 30 the transform-set ESP-3DES-ESP-SHA-HMAC-IPSec value

    VPN crypto card - 100 - isakmp dynamic Dyn - VPN ipsec

    interface card crypto VPN-card outside

    crypto ISAKMP allow outside

    crypto ISAKMP policy 10

    preshared authentication

    3des encryption

    md5 hash

    Group 2

    life 86400

    crypto ISAKMP policy 65535

    preshared authentication

    3des encryption

    sha hash

    Group 2

    life 86400

    access list ACL-remote ext ip 10.0.0.0 allow 255.255.255.0 192.168.1.0 255.255.255.0

    Thank you.

    Marcelo Pinheiro

    The problem is that the ASA has a crypto acl defined between host and network, while the remote end has to the network.

    Make sure that the acl is reversed.

  • Step how to configure ASA 5500 Series Security Services Module-10 (model: ASA-SSM-10)

    Dear support,

    I need to configure Security Services Module-10 (model: ASA-SSM-10) on my ASA 5510 firewall. Could you provide configuration step and how to connect to the module?

    Here is the information on the module

    ciscoasa (config) # sh Details of module 1
    The details of the Service module, please wait...
    ASA 5500 Series Security Services Module-10
    Model: ASA-SSM-10
    Hardware version: 1.0
    Serial number: JAF1115066U
    Firmware version: 1.0 (11) 2
    Software version: 1.0000 E1
    MAC address range: 001a.e268.5aa9 to 001a.e268.5aa9
    App name: IPS
    App status. : to the top
    App status. / / Desc:
    App version: 1.0000 E1
    Data of aircraft status: Up
    Status: to the top
    Mgmt IP addr: 133.1.9.144
    Web to MGMT ports: 443
    Mgmt TLS enabled: true

    your help is very appreciate.

    Thank you

    Best regards

    Hi Sothengse,

    Please find the samlpe on AIP SSM module configurations. You can go through this to begin with.

    http://www.Cisco.com/c/en/us/support/docs/security/ASA-5500-x-series-NEX...

    https://www.YouTube.com/watch?v=FgYU5ZXwk4g

    Concerning

    Knockaert

  • Installation of site to site VPN IPSec using PIX and ASA

    / * Style definitions * / table. MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name : « Table Normal » ; mso-tstyle-rowband-taille : 0 ; mso-tstyle-colband-taille : 0 ; mso-style-noshow:yes ; mso-style-priorité : 99 ; mso-style-qformat:yes ; mso-style-parent : » « ;" mso-rembourrage-alt : 0 à 5.4pt 0 à 5.4pt ; mso-para-margin : 0 ; mso-para-marge-bottom : .0001pt ; mso-pagination : widow-orphelin ; police-taille : 11.0pt ; famille de police : « Calibri », « sans-serif » ; mso-ascii-font-family : Calibri ; mso-ascii-theme-font : minor-latin ; mso-fareast-font-family : « Times New Roman » ; mso-fareast-theme-font : minor-fareast ; mso-hansi-font-family : Calibri ; mso-hansi-theme-font : minor-latin ; mso-bidi-font-family : « Times New Roman » ; mso-bidi-theme-font : minor-bidi ;}

    I am a site configuration to site IPSec VPN using a PIX515E to site A and ASA5520 to Site B.

    I have attached the lab diagram. Consider PIX and ASA are in default configuration, which means that nothing is configured on both devices.

    According to the scheme

    ASA5520

    External interface is the level of security 11.11.10.1/248 0

    The inside interface is 172.16.9.2/24 security level 100

    Default route is 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 11.11.10.2 1

    PIX515E

    External interface is the level of security 123.123.10.2/248 0

    The inside interface is 172.16.10.1/24 security level 100

    Default route is 0.0.0.0 0.0.0.0 123.123.10.1 1

    / * Style definitions * / table. MsoNormalTable {mso-style-name : « Table Normal » ; mso-tstyle-rowband-taille : 0 ; mso-tstyle-colband-taille : 0 ; mso-style-noshow:yes ; mso-style-priorité : 99 ; mso-style-qformat:yes ; mso-style-parent : » « ;" mso-rembourrage-alt : 0 à 5.4pt 0 à 5.4pt ; mso-para-margin : 0 ; mso-para-marge-bottom : .0001pt ; mso-pagination : widow-orphelin ; police-taille : 11.0pt ; famille de police : « Calibri », « sans-serif » ; mso-ascii-font-family : Calibri ; mso-ascii-theme-font : minor-latin ; mso-fareast-font-family : « Times New Roman » ; mso-fareast-theme-font : minor-fareast ; mso-hansi-font-family : Calibri ; mso-hansi-theme-font : minor-latin ; mso-bidi-font-family : « Times New Roman » ; mso-bidi-theme-font : minor-bidi ;}

    Could someone tell me how to set up this configuration? I tried but didn't workout. Here is the IKE protocol I have used.

    IKE information:

    IKE Encrytion OF

    MD5 authentication method

    Diffie Helman Group 2

    Failure to life

    IPSEC information:

    IPsec encryption OF

    MD5 authentication method

    Failure to life

    Please enter the following command

    on asa

    Sysopt connection permit VPN

    on pix not sure of the syntax, I think it is

    Permitted connection ipsec sysopt

    What we are trying to do here is basically allowing vpn opening ports

    Alternatively you can open udp 500 and esp (or port ip 50) out to in on the two firewalls

  • How to limit the ICMP on the PIX firewall.

    Guys good day!

    I have a dilemma with regard to limiting ICMP users browsing to other networks such as other demilitarized interns.

    I know that, to allow ICMP to pass through interfaces, you will need to create an ACL such as below:

    access-list DMZACL allow icmp a whole

    Users require this config ping a server on the DMZ, but it is a security risk.

    To minimize, I have a group of objects created in order to identify hosts and networks is allowed to have access to the echo-replies.

    Again, this is a problem since many host who extended pings just to monitor the connectivity server and its application.

    Do you have other ideas guys?

    As to limiting the echo answers on the PIX. As first 5 echo request succeed with 5 echo-replies and the rest would be removed.

    This could be done?

    Thank you

    Chris

    Hello.. I don't think you can do this by using an ACL on the PIX, however, you might be able to stop the ICMP sweeps by activating CODES signatures using the check ip command you... For more information see the link below

    Guidelines of use Cisco Intrusion Detection System (IDS Cisco) provides the following for IP-based systems:

    ? Audit of traffic. The application of signatures will be audited only as part of an active session.

    ? Apply to the verification of an interface.

    ? Supports different auditing policies. Traffic that matches a signature triggers a range of configurable

    actions.

    ? Disables signature verification.

    ? Always turns the shares of a class of signature and allows IDS (information, attack).

    The audit is performed by looking at IP packets to their arrival at an input interface, if a packet triggers

    a signature and the action configured does not have the package, and then the same package may trigger another

    signatures.

    Firewall PIX supports inbound and outbound audit.

    For a complete list signatures of Cisco IDS supported, their wording and whether they are attacking or

    informational messages, see Messages in Log System Cisco PIX Firewall.

    See the User Guide for the Cisco Secure Intrusion Detection System Version 2.2.1 for more information

    on each signature. You can view the? NSDB and Signatures? Chapter of this guide at the following

    website:

    http://www.Cisco.com/univercd/CC/TD/doc/product/iaabu/csids/csids1/csidsug/SIGs.htm

  • Why did after downloading Windows security updates that Windows Firewall starts immediately after opening?

    Why did after downloading Windows security updates that Windows Firewall starts immediately after the connection?   This is happening with my PC and netbook, I almost hesitate to download the safety of dates in the future

    Hello

    1. What is the security update article?
    2. are there any other security software installed on your computer?

    If you have any third-party security software installed on your computer, I suggest you to disable the security software and then check if it helps.

    Note : If you need to temporarily disable the security software, you should reactivate as soon as you are finished. If you are connected to the Internet or a network, while your antivirus software is disabled, your computer is vulnerable to attacks

    See also:

    The firewall service Windows in Windows XP Service Pack 2, in the edition of Windows XP Professional x 64, Windows Server 2003 SP1 and x 64 of Windows Server 2003 versions may not start if the DCOM Process Launcher Service is disabled: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/892504

    Troubleshooting settings of Windows Firewall in Windows XP Service Pack 2 for advanced users: http://support.microsoft.com/kb/875357

  • Cisco ACS and Pix Firewall

    I have configured the aaa authentication in the pix firewall to see the ACS RADIUS Server for verification of the user. If the ACS server becomes unavailable, then I could not connet the pix firewall.

    In the router, I have the configuration option

    AAA authentication login default group Ganymede + local

    that tells the router first looking for a radius server and if is not available connect through the local database.

    Is there an option in the Cisco pix firewall to connect using local information if ACS is not available?

    Thanks in advance

    Hello

    PIX back up method to entered the unit in the event of server failure aaa works on 6.3.4 code and above. In the codes plus late 6.3.4 If the RADIUS server fails it is impossible to get in unless password recovery. "However if we have not configured for console aaa authentication than user name: pix and password: cisco" works by default.

    Kind regards

    Mahmoud Singh

  • PIX firewall problem

    I have two servers, one in pix inside and the other in the demilitarized zone. I wanted to set them up so that they can communicate with routers and switches

    Located outside the pix firewall.

    My inner Server works fine, able to go Internet and able to comminicate with all devices located outside the Pix Firewall. Here is reference configuration

    of insideserver.

    outside_acl list extended access allowed host x.223.188.0 255.255.255.0 172.28.32.50 ip

    outside_acl list extended access permit ip host host x.219.212.217 172.28.32.50

    access-list extended sheep permit ip host 172.28.32.50 host x.219.212.217

    access-list extended sheep permit ip host 172.28.32.50 x.223.188.0 255.255.255.0

    inside_acl list extended access permit ip host 172.28.32.50 all

    But my DMZ server does not work. However, I made the same configuration with respect to the server on the inside. Not able to communicate with outside DMZ server

    network.

    outside_acl list extended access allowed host x.223.188.0 255.255.255.0 172.28.92.72 ip

    outside_acl list extended access permit ip host host x.219.212.217 172.28.92.72

    access-list extended sheep permit ip host 172.28.92.72 host x.219.212.217

    access-list extended sheep permit ip host 172.28.92.72 x.223.188.0 255.255.255.0

    dmz_acl list extended access permit ip host 172.28.92.72 all

    If I create a static entry for your DMZ SNMP server.

    static (edn, external) 172.28.92.72 172.28.92.72 netmask 255.255.255.255

    He starts to communicate with external devices, but stops Internet run on this server. same configuration

    works with the server on the inside, but not with dmz server.

    NAT (inside) 0 access-list sheep

    NAT (inside) 3 172.28.32.0 255.255.255.0

    NAT (dmz) 3 172.28.92.0 255.255.255.0

    Global interface 3 (external)

    Your static entry is bypassing your nat (dmz) 3 entry. You can do NAT exemption instead, as you do to your home

    1. remove the static entry (followed by clear xlate)

    Add - nat 0 access-list sheep (dmz)

    I suggest to use two acl different sheep, one for each interface.

    Ex: nonat_inside

    nonat_dmz

  • Allowing L2TP to pass through PIX Firewall

    Hi all

    Can someone help me on how to allow inbound l2tp connection on a pix? Behind the pix firewall, there is an ISA server as a vpn l2tp server. I can't allow l2tp on the pix.

    Thank you very much!

    Please use this doc as a guide-

    http://www.Cisco.com/en/us/products/HW/vpndevc/ps2030/products_configuration_example09186a0080094a5a.shtml

    Jon

  • How can I clear counters access-list on a pix firewall

    How can I erase the hitcounts on an on a pix firewall access list without resetting the pix?

    It would be clear access-list on a router counters.

    Thanks in advance

    Steve

    access list counters Clear

Maybe you are looking for