Company of ESX and Hyper-V

Hello

As the topic States ESX Enterprise and HyperV an old topic.

Right now were faced with a difficult decision that I was elected to do. We have been the assessment of VMware ESX Enterprise 3.5 in our environment for almost 2 years now and its been a great product and we love him. Especially features such as shared memory, the allocation of resources and the overcommittment. We used in a stand-alone (not SAN) environment.

However, with the recent release of HyperV we just sort of a State in which we need to reassess our virtualization solution. For us fortunately or not we have a blanket license with MS so all MS products are free from us, including all versions of HyperV.

So now that I need to make the decision between the 2, from my study of HyperV and usage of Enterprise ESX I find that it is a much more superior product for our environment - and now intend to move to the next step of the SAN. But before we even get there I need to somehow the VMware ESX Enterprise solution with its price around US$ 16000 against the free HyperV solution available.

For me some points I can think of for VMware is:

-Best active vs HyperV, which is based on the Windows CLustering so probably active clustering / passive is more appropriate (means we need a machine for HyperV standby)

-Memory sharing

-Control over failover since we can easily have different ESX hosts choose virtual machines and load any logic unit number in the SAN, then that HyperV as Windows cluster picks up a whole LUN that can contain multiple virtual machines

-Features like "Fault Tolerance", WINS VMware vMotion in these

But what I need to do, it's somehow justify spending an extra $16000 on ESX versus free HyperV that I find quite difficult. To start I tried cost/benefit calculation of the ratio of grouping given that consumes HyperV during the allocation of the resources of the VM takes the RAM once allocated from VMware that can share the memory save about 30%, but based on this alone, I do not think the additional VMs can I load on ESX is sufficient to cover the $16000 for the license of the company.

Can someone give other pointers or advice on what you think.

For others falling into the same situation where they compare hyper-v vs. VMware, I thought to let you know that ITComparison.com has updated their comparison in this respect & new can be found at:

MS Hyper - V R2 vs VMware ESX 4

I hope this helps someone, if she does not like Rewards points.

Enjoy,

WMD Al-Aqqad

System X & storage technical specialist

Founder of http://www.VirtualizationTeam.com

Tags: VMware

Similar Questions

  • Comparison between ESX 4, Xen and Hyper-V

    Hello!

    Someone at - it a (new) comparison between ESX 4, Xen and Hyper V? Management performance, stability, cost and so on.

    Thank you to

    Hello

    Visit this link for the last comparison http://www.it20.info/misc/virtualizationscomparison.htm

    http://ctistrategy.com/2009/08/18/VMware-vSphere-Microsoft-HyperV-whitepaper/

    If you found this information useful, please consider awarding points to 'Correct' or 'useful '. Thank you!!!

    Prakash

  • Using VMotion with 2 ESX and VCenter

    Hi all

    I just installed with ESX 2 VSphere and & VCenter. I can't use VMotion to migrate a virtual machine running one ESX towards each other.

    My setup is as follows:

    the iSCSI Software initiator.

    data store even shared by 2 facilitators.

    same conf network on the 2 hosts, none vlan used (set to 0):

    • vSwitch0 for the Service console, connected to the network of the company (vmnik0)

    • vSwitch1 for virtual machine network (connected to the company network vmnic1) and VMkernel (for vmotion, connected to the production network: san, vmnic2).

    Error displayed (at 10%): a general error occurred: the VMotion failed because the ESX host failed to connect to the VMotion network, please check your physical network configuration and settings network VMotion.

    vmnic2 on ESX1 is configured with 255.255.0.0 192.168.130.X mask and connected to eth0 on iSCSI SAN

    vmnic2 on ESX2 is configured with 255.255.0.0 192.168.131.X mask and connected to eth1 on iSCSI SAN

    Thanks for help

    alelievre wrote:

    vmnic2 on ESX1 is configured with 255.255.0.0 192.168.130.X mask and connected to eth0 on iSCSI SAN

    vmnic2 on ESX2 is configured with 255.255.0.0 192.168.131.X mask and connected to eth1 on iSCSI SAN

    Two VLAN different connection to the iSCSI SAN. You should have the same subnet, but a different IP addresses (if any) connecting to the San from each host (depends on the SAN)... For example 192.168.130.25 for ESX1 and 192.168.130.30 for ESX2. Unless your SAN network covers actually two subnets on your local network, you create a question where you don't need to. I would also use separate NETWORK card for vMotion traffic and another for iSCSI. Separate them VM traffic too (makes everything cleaner and less chance of collisions and too load performance causing one issues for each other. This is why it is a good idea to have at least four, if not six, physical NIC (or ports) within an ESX/ESXi server.

    VMware VCP4

    Review the allocation of points for "useful" or "right" answers.

  • Ping issues - Windows 2008 R2 and Hyper v2008

    Hello

    I'm looking for a few windows networking procedure of experts here to solve these 2 problems.

    I'm very good in Linux but not in windows, networks than some basics on windows of course.

    I installed Windows 2008 R2 and Hyper-v 2008 on two machines different level of "WORKING group" because I'm small laboratory

    I done the settting up the ip addresses static, of the hostname (s) on those computers.

    Windows 2008 R2 => 192.168.1.60 - obiee

    Hyper-v 2008 => 192.168.1.61 - hyperv2008

    I have DNS running on 192.168.1.10 server and my linux local dns host: narayana.local

    I can ping linux boxes ping, ping hyperv2008 obiee hostnames - works perfectly

    I have a few problems in the windows operating system

    (1) i cannot set my computer full qualified domain name say obiee.narayana.local, hyperv2008.narayana.local - it can be a low priority

    (2) i don't can't ping using host names of these 2 machines - priority issue, I get a message

    C:\Users\Administrators > ping hyperv2008

    Ping request could not find the hyperv2008 of the host. Please check the name and try again

    = I can ping IP_address - works perfectly =

    (3) in view of these questions I can't control my hyper-v to obiee machine.

    Waiting for your early resolution

    Ask in the forum Windows Server:
    http://social.technet.Microsoft.com/forums/en-us/category/WindowsServer

  • XPS 730 x company vista plug-and-play does not recognize the dell aio 962 printer

    XPS 730 x company vista plug-and-play does not recognize the dell aio 962 printer

    It is usually best to install the drivers before connecting the printer. Use the printer installation disk, if you have one, or follow the procedure here:

    http://support.Dell.com/support/topics/global.aspx/support/DSN/en/document?c=us&l=en&s=Gen&DN=TT1092882

  • What is the difference between containers and hyper-v server windows?

    Hello

    What is the difference between containers and hyper-v server windows?

    Thank you

    http://windowsitpro.com/Windows-Server-2016/differences-between-Windows-containers-and-hyper-v-containers-Windows-Server-201

    PS: Where's your homework due?

  • Store of data sharing between 4 ESX and ESXi 5

    Hello

    I have a vSphere environment 4.1 with a vCenter and a cluster of 3 ESX 4.1 access to the content of data through fiberchanel (type scneario) warehouses.

    And now I need to install a new ESXi 5.x (cannot be a different version) in a separate environment, outside of the current vCenter, BUT to access the warehouses of data even as the cluster of vSphere 4 current.

    Anyone know if there should be no problem sharing between 4 ESX and ESXi 5 access to the same data storage?

    Thanks in advance

    As long as the FC zoning is configured properly, avoid all the problems.   ESXi 5 will be able to see the data created by ESX4 VMFS3 stores, it will not be able to create the same size of virtual machine he can on a 5 VMFS datastore.

  • Need a powercli script to create a new account a local administrator on all ESX and ESXi hosts in the vcenter

    Hi all

    If someone can help me with a powercli script to create a new account a local administrator on all ESX and ESXi hosts in the vcenter, create a role called admin and give all access except the root. This shoulb be past by a virtual centre.

    Very much appreciated to help him.

    Kind regards

    MelLvin

    I suspect that you posted your question to the wrong thread

    This requires only a minor change to the script above actually.

    Something like that

    $groupName = "group"$accountName = "user"$accountPswd = "password"$accountDescription = "A user"
    
    $esxlist = Get-VMHostforeach($esx in $esxlist){    Connect-VIServer -Server $esx -User root -Password "password"
    
        Try {      Get-VMHostAccount -Id $groupName -Group -ErrorAction Stop | Out-Null    }    Catch {      New-VMHostAccount -Id $groupName -GroupAccount | Out-Null    }
    
        $rootFolder = Get-Folder -Name ha-folder-root    Try{        $account = Get-VMHostAccount -Id $accountName -ErrorAction Stop |        Set-VMHostAccount -Password $accountPswd -Description $accountDescription -AssignGroups $groupName    }    Catch{        $account = New-VMHostAccount -Id $accountName -Password $accountPswd -Description $accountDescription -UserAccount -GrantShellAccess -AssignGroups $groupName    }
    
        $rootFolder = Get-Folder -Name ha-folder-root    New-VIPermission -Entity $rootFolder -Principal $account -Role admin
    
        Disconnect-VIServer -Confirm:$false}
    
  • Question: ESX and vShield

    Hello

    I am conducting a study on the safety in the vrtual environment and I have a question about VMWare Hypervisors.

    ESX and adjustable vShield upward on the same server cluster? They both will remain as hypervisors? because from what I've read, I've heard that ESX and vShield are hypervisors and vShield is only for reasons of security, while ESX is a more general hypervisor...

    Could you confirm or explain my mistakes?

    Thank you

    ESXi is the hypervisor - taking the material resources of a host and delivering them to virtual machines. vShield provides a layer of security to the virtual environment using virtual machines / devices that run on the computer host ESXi - hope this clears up it

  • VMware Workstation and Hyper-V are not compatible. Remove the Hyper-V system role before running VMware Workstation

    Ouch. I just started to do some Win Phone 8 and development Win, and all simulators are needed for development.

    This means that a dev to Win8 may only work on their host... I'm sure it would work in a virtual machine.

    Can I make for happy? (Hyper V might have to win here... sigh).

    VMware Workstation and Hyper-V are not compatible. Remove the Hyper-V system role before running VMware Workstation

    Once you install the Hyper-V role on your host, your host is no longer running Windows 8 as the native operating system.  It runs Hyper-V as the native operating system, and Windows 8 runs as OS management within a privileged under Hyper-V VM.  With the Hyper-V role installed, * everything * runs in a virtual machine under Hyper-V.

    So to run a virtual machine under my computer in Windows 8 under Hyper-V, you must be able to run a nested VM.  It's possible with Hyper-V, the hypervisor host, but with the updates in custody, I mentioned above.

  • Script - missing and hotfixes installed for ESX and ESXi

    Can I have the script i.e. missing and hotfixes installed for ESX and ESXi using the CLI power only? out put should be csv format

    You reset the content of the table $Results on each iteration of the baseline.

    Try like this

    $Results = @()
    foreach($esx in Get-VMHost) {
      foreach($baseline in (Get-Compliance -Entity $esx -Detailed | where {$_.Status -eq "NotCompliant"})){
        $Results += $baseline.CompliantPatches |    Select @{N="Host";E={$esx.Name}},    @{N="Status";E={"Compliant"}},    @{N="Baseline";E={$baseline.Baseline.Name}},Name,ReleaseDate,IdByVendor,    @{N="KB";E={(Select-String "(?http://[\w|\.|/]*\w{1})" -InputObject $_.Description).Matches[0].Groups['url'].Value}}
    
        $Results += $baseline.NotCompliantPatches |    Select @{N="Host";E={$esx.Name}},    @{N="Status";E={"NotCompliant"}},    @{N="Baseline";E={$baseline.Baseline.Name}},Name,ReleaseDate,IdByVendor,    @{N="KB";E={(Select-String "(?http://[\w|\.|/]*\w{1})" -InputObject $_.Description).Matches[0].Groups['url'].Value}}
      }
    }
    $Results
    

    It will give the installed and lack of patches which are defined in the non-compliant baslines related to the ESXi host.

    If you want to see all the lines, also the most consistent, omit the Where clause on the base line (foreach) loop.

  • ESX and ESXi

    What are the fundamental differences between ESX and ESXi. Someone could it say please interview point of view. Just need about 4 to 5 differences.

    Thank you

    Prashant

    The difference between ESX and ESXi, ESX was the classic version with a dedicated Service console embarked with him, however, ESXi is the version of Vsphere without the Console service. Because ESXi is without the service console, so its size is very small and its called summer have footprint small disc. With the release of VSphere VMware 5.0 and later versions has deprecated the classic ESX version there is therefore no now unavailable ESX and we only ESXi now.

  • Differences between ESX and ESXi

    Hai,

    As I am new to VI environment I doubt that where features ESX and ESXi are different, it may be stupid but can help me a lot.

    Hello

    Please check the link to the differences between ESX and ESXi below.

    http://www.VMware.com/products/vSphere/ESXi-and-ESX/compare.html

    Please note ESX is present in version 3.x, 4.x. starting vsphere 5.0, we have only ESXi.

    ESXi doesnot have a service console and has the smallest footprint of 70 MB and so is safer and more reliable, because it has a smaller surface set.

    Please allow points if you find the article useful.

    Thank you

    Aakash Jacob

  • DRS cluster: You can mix 4.1 ESX and ESXi 4.1?

    Not very complext, but we have a DRS cluster of 8 hosts x 3850 of IBM on ESX 4.1 and we will upgrade them both to ESXi 4.1 update 1.  There will be questions mixing a cluster of ESX and ESXi servers?

    Yes, 100% supported!  both are the same hypervisor, so you should have no problem running in the same cluster.  After all it is the best way to do a upgrade spread, and how we made our move between ESX and ESXi.

  • VMotion with ESX and ESXi in the same cluster.

    My client wants to spend his whole army ESX 4.0 to ESXi 4.1 host. I know that it requires a clean install of the host. But vMotion always works in a cluster with a mix of the host ESX 4.0 and ESXi 4.1?

    You will be fine to have a mixed group of ESX and ESXi hosts.

    Dave

    VMware communities user moderator

    Now available - vSphere Quick Start Guide

    You have a system or a PCI with VMDirectPath?  Submit your specifications to Officieux VMDirectPath HCL.

Maybe you are looking for

  • Satellite A500 and Kernel-Power problem

    Computer stops responding or displays the blue screen or restart unexpectedly. I followed these steps and could not solve my problem. Help, please... 1. perform a clean boot device to determine if it is caused by the incompatible driver. 1) click "St

  • Cannot enlarge an image after it scans to my computer

    Original title: hp all-in-one I can scan a photo and get it in my pic, but I can't expand. only print the size I scan or smaller. Help

  • XP installation problems

    My computer broke down recently. I have the cd of windows XP Home Edition. When I try to put the cd in and "install windows" it tells me these things... -Setup cannot continue because the version of Windows on your computer is newer than the version

  • laptop HP G530us: user profile service is a not the newspaper cannot be loaded

    What should I do to re-establish my connection? It was working fine, then all of a sudden, I get the above message.

  • My Dell c1765nfw looks like a Jackhammer

    What impression my Dell c1765nfw let out a deafening as a percussion drill noise that lasts as long as the print operation. The print quality is very good and there is no noise when the printer is idle. Anyone know what could be the problem and offer