Images from Lightroom do not look the same when opened in PSCS5

Hello

I use LR 3 and PS CS5, but an annoying problem that I don't know how to fix. Basically, when I look at a picture in the window inside LR 3, obviously true insofar the contrast and saturation and hue... when I select Edit in Photoshop CS5, the file opens in the PS, but the contrast and saturation and the same hue are a little off. Why?

Thank you

Juan

Juan, note that in Lightroom develop didn't use all the raw data available at a time to give you an overview. She does as otherwise, the program would be unusably slow. Each movement of a slider should give rise to a complete rerendering of the data at full resolution and then reduce the image resolution of the screen. Even on very fast machines out there that lasts about one second that would make all glacial especially on normal computers. So in a zoomed view outside, it takes just a subset of the raw data at lower resolution and uses for rendering. This can subtly affect the saturation in cases where there are a lot of specific details of the colors because there are no average before reaching the lower res image. When you zoom to 1:1, Lightroom simply makes only the small subset of the image you see in your window. Because it is a small subset, it is still once very fast, but is now done at full resolution. To develop, you can only 1:1 see Lightroom apply the noise reduction and levels of sharpening that can also affect the saturation similar to zoom out. Certainly, this will remain a problem until we are a few generations further down the curve of Moore. However, at this time there, the resolution of the cameras will have increased by the same amount as the rest of the problem.

Now consider what happens when you go to Photoshop. Lightroom (or ACR when you use "Edit in Photoshop") reproduces the image of the raw usually a TIFF 16 bit prophotoRGB. It is then opened in Photoshop. Photoshop doesn't know how to deal with RAW files. He needs a fully rendered RGB image provided by ACR or Lightroom. Now, since you have a fully rendered image, downward revision is very easy. However, you have more freedom to reinterpret raw data. The model used in Photoshop is very different from Lightroom and so different restrictions apply.

In the Lightroom library views, a prerendered jpeg is used for the display. This means that, in library view, the image is reduced to a fully rendered image and should show a desaturation with respect to develop when you have a lot of specific color details. Note that neither Lightroom overview of the library and scaled down preview Photoshop are actually accurate. The two scale in a corrected gamma space, but for display only. To complicate this, Lightroom evolves down using a different algorithm than Photoshop (which uses several mechanisms based on the zoom level - i.e. If it is divisible by two).  It is simply impossible to precisely display a picture in high resolution on a computer screen very low resolution. Always deal with scaling, for which there is no more correct approach. They have questions (stupid method of Photoshop has certainly).

Finally, a lot of people who see subtle (or even extreme) differences between Photoshop and Lightroom do have a problem with their monitor profile. Make sure calibrate you re - your monitor, and when you do, make sure that the calibration software generates a v2 profile (most profiling software have this option in advanced settings). Lightroom treats LUT v4 unlike Photoshop monitor profile. This difference will be left in a matrix of v2 profile.

Tags: Photoshop Lightroom

Similar Questions

  • Why Lightroom will not save the file when you use the image Capture?

    When you work with video in Lightroom 5, whenever I press "Image Capture", I get an error message that says: "cannot save the file." I tried this on several video files, and I get the same message. Video files are. MOV files. I can't understand why this is happening!

    I had this same error message. I solved it when I moved the video file on the hard disk internal to the computer, and then it worked perfectly. He always gave the error message when I used an external video file from my hard drive. There for a long time until I tried this. No one answered this problem in forums that I could find.

    I hope this helps.

  • Does anyone know why my images in InDesign do not have the same quality as in Photoshop?

    Hello world

    I'm new to InDesign, but I did a course accelerated and also does research in Google on poor quality images in InDesign.  I am having trouble with the quality of the images.

    I'm working on a magazine.  I started with the addition of advertising, first of all, some of the pictures I get from the internet and when I save them and import them into photoshop the quality is excellent.

    Then I save as a PSD file and export for the web saved in JPEG, the highest quality.

    I have sizes in Photoshop and InDesign, predefined

    I have the images in InDesign display quality.  Or, what I have to do before I import the photo?

    Any help would be greatly appreciated.

    Emma

    Low resolution preview is the deafult, but you can change that in your preferences. I don't see anything in what you are doing that should cause a problem unless you're enlaging images in InDesign.

    I don't do things online, just print, so I do tend to work with images low resolution at all, but I guess it is possible that the quality is better, if you start with a high resolution image and make the downsampling on the conversion. Someone who regularly does this type of export would be a better resource. There are a number of threads, but on the quality problems with .swf exported if you look around.

    Peter

  • My video library fills up with many weird image files that are not of the same videos.

    WMP is allowing hundreds of files to load in the video library.  What can I do to stop it?

    WMP is allowing hundreds of files to load in the video library.  What can I do to stop it?

    Maybe you need to restore the default libraries.

    Here's how: -.
    http://www.Winhelponline.com/blog/fix-error-library-MS-is-no-longer-working-Windows-7/

    [In your case, it will be video]

  • Lightroom will not validate the gmail password

    Hi everyone I am trying to send my images from Lightroom, but he continues to throw an error that my email password is not validated.

    Someone at - it a fix for this problem?

    I can only send an image from Lightroom by export to a folder outside, opening of gmail & import image to send.

    Thank you for your help in advance. John was soon

    Hi johnmjay,

    Please see the discussion below.

    Validation of Gmail failure

    Let us know if that helps.

    Kind regards.

    Mohit

  • Whenever I export an image from lightroom, if I try to work on the original again once he said immediately that the file is not found.

    As noted above, immediately after you export an image in a file - if I want to go back to work on this image it just says that the file is not found. I have not changed the name of the file.

    Also, after work on an image in Photoshop and saves a copy to the lightroom folder - I don't find it anywhere. It works if I save on the original image from lightroom, but if I save a copy I can't find it in the file anywhere!

    Hi mayab13,

    How do you export the image from Lightroom, because export image from Lightroom keeps the image in Lightroom.

    Could you please tell me your step by step workflow.

    Kind regards

    Tanuj

  • Lightroom displays all images from a folder - it displays the message '45 65 images, selected 45' and 45 messages do not appear in the grid of the library, but I can't see the remaining images of 20. All filters are disabled...

    Lightroom displays all images from a folder - it displays the message '45 65 images, selected 45' and 45 messages do not appear in the grid of the library, but I can't see the remaining images of 20. All filters are disabled...

    Hello

    Please go to the library Module, then click on the picture in the Menu bar and then click the stacking.

    From there please select expand all stack them.

    It should show all the images if they are virtual copies.

    Kind regards

    Tanuj

  • How to export images and they look the same on all devices (iPhone, mac, desktop computer book)

    Hello

    I have adobe lightroom cc 2016 and I'm having the hardest time export photos, especially those where I use adjustment brushes and have look the same on all devices, my man book retna I will edit to look how I want, but for example when I look at the same image on the desktop mac dessu I can see all the adjustment brushes I used to darken

    on the 2 pictures below

    the first is what I see, its all uniformly dark and when I look on another device, according to me, which is depicted in the second photo

    (I have more exposed the second to show what I mean)

    I do not know what device who's going to be watching this post, but I hope you can help!

    Thank you! don't know what to do

    IMG_1204.jpgIMG_1204-2.jpg

    To ensure maximum viewing compatibility make sure you set the colorspace of the export in sRGB as below:

  • Photoshop CS-6 does not open images from Lightroom 5

    I don't have Photoshop CS-6 and Lightroom 5.  Almost all of the images have been created in an environment Windows 7 (64-bit).  I moved to Mac platforms. I moved all the images and the catalog. I changed on Mac platform. I'm now using MAC OS - X (10.9.1).

    I am able to see images in Lightroom, I'm able to edit images in Lightroom. I can export the images to JPEG (for example) from Lightroom.  I have a warning to several images in Lightroom = ' metadata were changed - you want to replace the data or import?

    First time I tried to open an Image in Photoshop Lightroom (back) opens, but does not show a picture and no error message. But when I then look at the recently opened files, the image is in the list. When I click on this point, Photoshop displays, and the error message: "the datamodule can't handle the file format" (which is either RAW or jpeg).

    Another expirience is when I try to open any other image directly from within Photoshop, Photoshop skips the XMP and open the original unmodified file.

    Somehow, there must be a bug, I tried everything without success.  But now I have a good "workaround." I created an export preset in Lightroom that exports my psd image, the last step to open the image in Phtoshop. The only thing you need to do is to remove the psd file, when you don't need it anyymore (for example when I don't use a Photoshop export feature). But the "Workaround" is very uncomfortable.

  • Tips on how to get attached with Nikon D810 and Lightroom - I tried with the uSB cable but Lightroom does not recognize the camera. My memory card has no images on it that I read somewhere that it can slow things down if it has pictures on i

    I tried to use the uSB cable, but Lightroom does not recognize the camera. My memory card has no images on it that I read somewhere that it can slow things down if she has no images on it

    If you use Lightroom CC / 6 on a Mac OSX El Capitan you must update to the latest version of CC 2015.4 / 6.4. Problems with Nikon capture home has been fixed in the latest update, the lis below.

    Lightroom Journal | Tips and advice straight from the Lightroom team.

  • Edit an image from lightroom to photoshop... Image does not open.

    When I want to edit an image from Lightroom to Photoshop (CC), Photoshop opens, but the image does not work. However, I am still able to do with some images, but some images are simply no opening. This is the time of fisrt I have this problem.


    My version of photoshop is CS5 extended.


    I have Lightroom 6.0.


    I'm with P.C.


    Thank you

    Photoshop Cs5 will not open images Nikon D750

    You must use the version of Photoshop cs6/CC or DNG converter to be able to view these images in Photoshop cs5 in DNG

    Download DNG Converter:-Adobe - Adobe Camera Raw and DNG Converter: for Windows: Adobe DNG Converter 9.2

    Concerning

    Assani

  • How to restore pictures that have been deleted from Lightroom, but not removed from the 'drive '?

    How to restore pictures that have been deleted from Lightroom, but not removed from the 'drive '? Also, how can I restore photos after saving Lightroom. I started to remove some files and it removed ALL of them! I chose the option "cancel delete files" and them brought back, she says they are all "missing or offline. I tried to 'find' a different folder and it deleted the folder all together and now I don't know where he is. Help, please!

    How to restore pictures that have been deleted from Lightroom, but not removed from the 'drive '?

    You need a backup of your Lightroom catalog file before deleting the photos made. You have such a backup? If so, find the backup catalog, open it (double click on it) and then search for the photos you want and select them and then file-> export catalogue; Then go to your original catalog file, open it and select file-> import from another catalog and points to the catalog that you just exported.

    If you do not have a backup of your catalog file, then the only thing you can do is to import the photos again, and Lightroom will treat them as totally new photos with no editing and no metadata provided by the user.

    Moreover, the idea of importing photos into Lightroom and then later removing them to Lightroom should is limited to photos you will EVER want such a photos that are so overexposed or underexposed or blurred that they are essentially useless. The photos that you care enough to run a task on (including editing) should never be removed from Lightroom.

    Also, how can I restore photos after saving Lightroom.

    Is this the same problem as above, or another?

    I chose the option "cancel delete files" and them brought back, she says they are all "missing or offline.

    Is it possible that you actually deleted pictures from the hard disk, as well as from Lightroom? Anyway, Lightroom cannot find the photos and you first need to find photos on your hard drives and then direct Lightroom to the location of the photo on your hard drive, using these instructions Adobe Lightroom - find folders and files moved or missing

  • My problem is that when I try to save an image from Adobe Photoshop by using the 'save for Web' half of the dialog box does not appear.

    I use a Vista Home Premiuim Windows in an Acer Aspire One 10.1 "." My problem is that when I try to save an image from Adobe Photoshop by using the 'save for Web' half of the dialog box does not appear. Can someone help me please?

    Here is a screenshot of my problem...
    [IMG] http://i55.tinypic.com/of5w01.png [line]
    Help me please.

    Hello

    1. were you able to see the front dialog box?

    2. did you of recent changes to the computer?

    This happens because your screen resolution is less than the required minimum of 1024 x 768.

    You can try to change the resolution of the monitor and check.

    For more information, see the link:

    Change settings display on multiple monitors

    Change the screen resolution

    You can also refer to Adobe support links and also post your request in the Forum from Adobe for assistance:

    http://forums.Adobe.com/thread/433020?TSTART=0

    http://kb2.Adobe.com/CPS/403/kb403268.html

    http://forums.Adobe.com/community/Photoshop/photoshop_windows

    Hope this information is useful.

  • I just bought a version of lightroom upgrade 6 (mac, upgrade from lightroom 4) and began the process of installation, but when I entered the serial number of the previous version, I got the message "the serial number you entered is not valid. Please try

    I just bought a version of lightroom upgrade 6 (mac, upgrade from lightroom 4) and began the process of installation, but when I entered the serial number of the previous version, I got the message "the serial number you entered is not valid. Please try again. If the problem persists, contact customer service. The number I entered is correct - I checked against the original package and on the products of my adobe account page, and I get the error message even if I try to enter the serial number of the version of lightroom 3 I had before. I am at a loss to understand what I can do: I paid for this product, but I can't install it. The only thing I can think is that the lightroom 4A was purchased from an old computer, but it has migrated successfully to my current imac, as surely, it should work.

    Problem is resolved now - it's due to my misunderstanding of what was required, and enter the serial number of the previous version (as an upgrade) instead of the serial number of the version I had to buy). My apologies for my mistake and thank you for your time.

  • Develop module, 1:1 and export don't look the same, color questions

    Hello world

    I use the latest version of Lightroom (3.6 if I'm not mistaken) and I am facing a problem very uncomfortable with the develop module.

    I adjusted with precision each luminance of the color and saturation, so it looks pretty good in the preview to develop (made to fit) and did an export...

    The preview that I worked on and export just don't look the same.

    I work with files my DSLR digital D3100 from NIKON on an OSX Mac NAVE 10.7 MBP.

    This may be the external display profile is not properly adjusted because I looked at all the images on the same screen.

    I unchecked all boxes from the preset in the settings window tab.

    Here are some screenshots and exports.

    Good look in the module development (left) and the actual export of the same photo (right)

    Screen Shot 2012-01-27 at 17.32.06.PNGexport.jpg

    Please note that I have not activated an option for correction of lens and adjusted any color. This is the RAW file and its direct export.

    Screenshot of the preview window on the noise correction options (left) and the same area once as I zoomed in the main view (right)

    Screen Shot 2012-01-27 at 17.41.24.PNGScreen Shot 2012-01-27 at 17.41.30.PNG

    I hope this can be fixed or I'm doing something wrong.

    A few days before today I used Camera RAW of PS CS5 to correct my NAVE and maintaining only to exports to JPEG. I decided to use LR 3 on my entire workflow and I'm skeptical...

    Ah yes and please forget all mystake alone in my post, I'm a french student.

    Thank you!

    EDIT: I can meet any required file or the screenshot if necessary. I have a few other photos with the same problem (lots of those indeed...)

    EDIT 2: I found the image has made many more colors acurate (relative to export ones) in the library preview module (magnifying glass I guess)

    The previews in the library are are on JPEGs in a smaller color space.

    adobeRGB. Not in prophotoRGB, which is space (with linear gamma, but which)

    is a detail) used to develop. To make the point, you see the more accurate color

    in general, but you must be aware that not all destinations can actually

    reproduce these colors. There is also still the color noise reduction

    question, you can only see to develop at the 1:1. In the library, because it is

    made a jpeg file, the color noise reduction is applied at each zoom

    level images etc. like this, which tends to desaturate the colors. My guess

    is that this is probably a problem of range. You can check receives in

    Photoshop for adobeRGB profile. The orange on the trees is probably

    always out of gamut.

    That said, how do you calibrate? You should use a Spyder, Huey Pro,

    i1Display, Colormunki or similar to calibrate the screen if you want to

    believe what you see.

Maybe you are looking for