WLC4402-25-K9 vs HP Procurve MSM760

We are planning to upgrade to WLC 4402 w / 25 AP license but must justify our choice over other brands such as HP. someone used MSM760 from HP? It's only a litte over $ 2000 with software license 40 aps, fast roaming, location services, optimization 11n, and built-in firewall.

I like the installer HREAP for Cisco WLC. I am currently using a WLC 2106. I need to deploy a total of 18 APs throughout our WAN (switchis T1 links). I don't know if HP has the equivalent of HREAP. My problem is WLC 4402-25AP about 10 grand, much more expensive than HP. It is difficult for me to justify to management.

Can someone shed some light on this? I can't find anyone on google that is using HP. None of my sellers engineers (CDW, PC connection, etc.) have a hands-on experience with it. Does this mean that the HP controller is just hype? Sorry if I have offended the people of Cisco on the forum.

Thank you

Daniel

You can see this shoot out by cisco, hp, mototola, and aruba... HP has taken a beating... I posted this on my site a few weeks ago...

http://www.my80211.com/home/2009/11/29/Cisco-80211n-shootout-with-arubamotorola-and-HP.html

If you find it useful please note the post... Thank you

Tags: Cisco Wireless

Similar Questions

  • ProCurve 2610

    2910-al example hp configuration: 2 LAN switch and backplane with management LAN (cluster HA). Background basket of interconnection example

    These instructions assume that you configure a button for employment in two switches, LAN and backplane with LAN management and interconnection. If you use a different configuration, modify the steps according to the case.

    To assign ports, follow these steps:
    1. in the VLAN Menu, highlight the Port of VLAN assignment and press ENTER. The Port assignment screen opens.
    2. use the arrows on the Action-> menu to select modify and press ENTER. You can now change the information on this screen.
    3. set each port on Forbid to the DEFAULT_VLAN by selecting the parameter in the column for the VLAN, and then press space.
    4. Select Port 1 as the Uplink of VLAN LAN / Mgmt to connect your cluster to the rest of your network.
    5. set network LAN to Untagged.
    6. set network BACKPLANE VLAN to Forbid.
    7 Select Port 2 as the VLAN backplane
    Uplink port to connect the two switches together for the network VLAN BACKPLANE.
    8. for background basket ports, the value Ports 17-24 to allow 8 knots without any adjustment of switch VLAN Untagged. (For Option 3: single switch, rack only with the management of LAN, defined Ports 2-24)
    to Untagged.)
    How to steps 4 and 7.
    8 throws me a loop for, because I'm supposed to do step 6?

    Hello:

    You can also ask your question in the Forum of HP Business - section ProCurve switches Support.

    http://h30499.www3.HP.com/T5/ProCurve-provision-based/BD-p/switching-e-series-Forum#.Uel_BL4o69I

  • HP ProCurve 2920 - 48G: HP ProCurve 2920 - 48G with the issue of SFP

    Question: With copper connected between the two baskets on 20 Port (VLAN2), I have was ping another basket. But when we restart the switches with fiber Port 45 (VLAN2) instead of the cooper between two baskets, I cannot not ping another basket. Both switches HP report their 45 Port "Port State" as UP. Also tried combinations of the trunk (with Trk1) and flow control to the two switches, but no change.

     

    Rack A Rack & B;

    HP ProCurve J7928A SFP J4858C equipped port in port 45-48

    -VLAN1 untagged 1-15

    -VLAN2 untagged 16-30 & 45

    -VLAN3 untagged 31-44

    -Ports 1-44;

    -Type: 100/1000 t

    -Mode: Auto

    -Frother: disabled

    -Distribution limited: 0

    -LACP Status: Disabled

    -Type safe: no

    -Group master: no

    -Port45;

    -Type: 1000SX

    -Mode: Auto

    -Frother: enabled

    -Distribution limited: 0

    -LACP Status: Disabled

    -Type safe: no

    -Group master: no

    Cable;

    -2 x Orange fiber Multimode

    Hi, I made a household of VLAN and put 45-48 ports in the same VLAN, and it pings another grid very well now. Weird why SFP ports needed to be together.

  • HP Procurve vlan voice with trunks

    Hi all

    I am a trained guy cisco, so I try to transfer my knowledge to the HP Procurve switches but it takes a little help to obtain VLAN etc set up.

    What I have is 4 switches, 3 at the access layer to the and 1 to the base and distribution.

    I want that switches to a trunk of the base and distribution layer 2 interfaces access layer allows to increase the speed of 2 instead of 1 gigabit uplink. Also, I want is that 2 VLANS is set up for separate voice and data. I want that all ports to be able to take in charge a PC or a VOIP phone. I put the phones to automatically tag the tag of vlan for the vlan voice, but I want all traffic to forward the link to resources shared at the base and distribution layer.

    From what I understand, so I need to:

    Configure a network interface on the access and use of basic/distribution layer switches: b1 - b2 trk1 lacp trunk

    Add VLAN for voice and data and assign vlan voice.

    The problem I have is the tag-no identified parameters.

    I tag vlan trk1 voice and set the priority of the qos to 6 and then comes to create the vlan data not marked on trk1?

    the config I've written so far is:

    b1 - b2 trk1 lacp trunk
    show trunks
    spanning tree
    spanning tree force version rstp operation
    voice VLAN 100 name
    voice
    Tagged trk1
    QoS priority 6
    data name VLAN 200
    not tagged trk1

    is this correct or am I missing something here?

    Thanks in advance!

    Hello:

    You can also copy and paste your message into the HP Business Support Forum - section Procurve switches.

    http://h30499.www3.HP.com/T5/ProCurve-provision-based/BD-p/switching-e-series-Forum

  • Firmewareupgrade failed - HP ProCurve 1810 G - 8 GE, P.1.6

    Hi @ all,

    I have a HP ProCurve 1810 G - 8 GE, eCos P.1.6, - 2.0.

    I tried to update the Firmeware P.1.6 initial P.1.17 or P.1.20, but without success.

    1 these are the steps I've tried:

    HTTP P.1.17 > Image "Backup" (with Windows & Linux Client)

    TFTP P.1.17 > Image "Backup" (with Windows & Linux TFTP Server)

    HTTP P.1.20 > Image "Backup" (with Windows & Linux Client)

    TFTP P.1.20 > Image "Backup" (with Windows & Linux TFTP Server)

    2. environment:

    OS1: Windows 7 x 64 (physical Machine)

    OS2: Ubuntu 14.04 (physical Machine)

    TFTP Server Windows 1: Tftpd32

    TFTP Server Windows 2: SolarWinds TFTP server

    TFTP Server Ubuntu: tftpgui (https://code.google.com/p/tftpgui/)

    No static IP address of firewall, without DHCP,

    PC1 PC2 & <> Switch - directly connected with LAN (not cross-over) cable

    1 x CAT5e cable (0.5 m) cable

    1 x CAT6 (1 meter) cable

    3. HTTP error messages:

    Download for IMAGE1 failed. Not enough memory to download the "P_1_17.stk".

    Download for valMapImage1 failed. File 'P_1_17.stk' does exist or is empty.

    Download for IMAGE1 failed. Not enough memory to download the "P_1_20.stk".

    Download for valMapImage1 failed. File 'P_1_20.stk' does exist or is empty.

    4 TFTP Error Messages (Windows and Linux):

    Not enough memory to complete the download of the file.

    The file download failed!

    6. note:

    -tried the clear on the switch button > without success

    -tried the reset switch button > without success

    -tried all ports with each cable with each client > unsuccessfully

    Now I don't know what to do now. Does anyone have a solution for me?

    With friendships

    Cookie

    P.S: Sorry for my English I'm a German speaker. :-)

    Hello:

    You can also ask your question on the Business - section switches Procurve HP Support Forum.

    http://h30499.www3.HP.com/T5/ProCurve-provision-based/BD-p/switching-e-series-Forum#.VCgRxHl0y9I

  • HP ProCurve 1800 - 24G of cascade switches

    Hello

    I have the following problem. I would like to connect/stack 3 switches not by RJ45 cables copper (which I do now), but by a cascading system or optical cables. In fact, I would have preferred cascading but I don't know if this is possible with my devices. My system looks like this now

    [1] proCurve 1810 - 24G J9450A software ver. ?
    |
    |
    [2] the software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    |
    |
    [3] software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    [3A] Here's a ProCurve Gigabit-SX-LC Mini-GBIC with full duplex LC connector
    |
    The switch below ([4]) is in a different location, so no need of it cascading! I wanted to just make sure that you notice that on the switch [3] an optical port is already in use. But I don't know if this generation switches are supported two optical ports that are used at the same time?
    |
    [4] the software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    [4b] Here's a ProCurve Gigabit-SX-LC Mini-GBIC with full duplex LC connector

    In the near future, my system will look like this:

    Nortel Avaya 4524GT [0]
    |   [0] here a SFP Gigabit Ethernet Transceiver connected to another switch Nortel Avay 4524GT
    |?
    |
    [1] proCurve 1810 - 24G J9450A software ver. ?
    |
    |
    [2] the software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    |
    |
    [3] software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    [3A] Here's a ProCurve Gigabit-SX-LC Mini-GBIC with full duplex LC connector
    |
    The switch below is in another place so no need of it cascading! I wanted to just make sure that you notice that on the switch [3] an optical port is already in use. But I don't know if this generation switches are supported two optical ports that are used at the same time?
    |
    [4] the software J9028A proCurve 1800 - 24G worm. PB.02.09
    [4b] Here's a ProCurve Gigabit-SX-LC Mini-GBIC with full duplex LC connector

    Once again, my question: is there a way to cascade [1], [2] and [3]. If so, how and how much can I add [0]?

    Thank you a lot for solutions...

    Hello

    As mentioned above, I did not use copper cables for this type of configuration so I don't know, BUT for optical cables, it should work.

    Kind regards.

  • MSM760 welcome page on the external server configuration

    Hi all

    Please help us to understand and configure the following:

    1. our MSM760 controller work with e-MSM430 APs in L3;
    2. we configuration and monitoring of the various local networks for different clients.
    3. in case of we need to provide some VSC welcome page is possible do not bring and put all the traffic in the controller? The problem is that if we do this the most. Speed DL/UL for the end user is less than 5 Mbps and w/o controller of more than 15 Mbps homepage.

    How to re-route traffic outside MSM760?

    Thank you

    Nikolai.

    Nikolai,

    You are in the forum of finished consumer products.  You want to ask your question on to the Enterprise Business Community.

    Click on the plus sign (+) next to the Forums of Discussion fall all server options, networking and any other problem of professional equipment.

    http://h30499.www3.HP.com/

    Good luck.

  • WLC4402 - switch problem

    Hello, Im new in the wireless. IM want to connect AIR-WLC4402-25-K9 in my lab with switch cisco 3560. WLC I have two 1000Base-T RJ-45 ports connected to GigE

    switch Cisco 3560 (FastEthernet). WLC I LAG activated interface an ap - manager in the same network as the interface of the Manager. I have two FastEthernet with configuration switch cisco 3560:

    interface FastEthernet0/1

    switchport trunk encapsulation dot1q

    switchport trunk allowed vlan 3,10,40,70

    switchport mode trunk

    Speed 100

    full duplex

    channel-group mode 5 on

    interface FastEthernet0/2

    switchport trunk encapsulation dot1q

    switchport trunk allowed vlan 3,10,40,70

    switchport mode trunk

    Speed 100

    full duplex

    channel-group mode 5 on

    Interface Port-channel5

    switchport trunk encapsulation dot1q

    switchport trunk allowed vlan 3,10,40,70

    switchport mode trunk

    but on my WLC I status link down:

    Cisco controller) > show port summary

    STP Admin physical physical link link Mcast

    Type of PR Stat Mode Mode trap POE device status

    -- ------- ---- ------- ---------- ---------- ------ ------- --------- -------

    1 normal Disa down Auto Enable enable Enable n/a

    2 normal Disa Enable Auto down Activate activate s/o

    Please help, how to establish a connection between the switch and WLC.

    Nesha cordially

    Unfortunately, FastEthernet is not an option with the WLC4400s. They require 1000/Full interfaces or they will not come to the top. You must connect the WLC gigabit interfaces.

  • AIR-WLC4402-25-K9 and AIR-WLC2125-K9

    Hello

    I have 20 ROUND 1131 G to deploy with a wireless controller and I have to choose between the AIR-WLC4402-25-K9 and AIR-WLC2125-K9. I would like to khnow the main differance between this espacially products in terms of performance (throughput).

    Thanks in advance

    Anita Nizar

    Hi Anita,

    Cisco documentation;

    "While Cisco 2100 series wireless LAN controllers supports transactional environments such as handheld scanners in retail wireless, Cisco 4400 series wireless LAN controllers are recommended for applications, high speed and high intensity of multicast such as bulky, videos, push-to-talk data files."

    Series 2100 Cisco Wireless LAN controllers

    http://www.Cisco.com/en/us/prod/collateral/wireless/ps6302/ps8322/ps7206/ps7221/product_data_sheet0900aecd805aaab9.html

    I hope this helps!

    Rob

  • Enable Snmp - Hp Procurve 2848

    Hi all

    I don't know why the snmp Protocol does not work on my Hp procurve 2848. (ping and interface web work!)

    This is my config.

    SW3_STIPA(config)# show config
    
    Startup configuration:
    
    ; J4904A Configuration Editor; Created on release #I.10.70
    
    hostname "SW3_STIPA"
    snmp-server contact "STIPA"
    snmp-server location "Montreuil"
    no cdp run
    interface 1
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 2
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 3
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 4
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 5
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 6
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 7
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 8
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 9
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 10
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 11
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 12
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 13
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 14
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 15
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 16
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 17
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 18
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 19
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 20
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 21
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 22
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 23
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 24
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 25
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 26
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 27
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 28
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 29
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 30
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 31
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 32
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 33
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 34
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 35
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 36
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 37
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 38
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 39
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 40
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 41
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 42
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 43
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 44
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 45
       name "INTERCO_VERS_SW1"
       no lacp
    exit
    interface 46
       name "INTERCO_VERS_SW1"
       no lacp
    exit
    trunk 45-46 Trk2 Trunk
    ip default-gateway 192.168.12.1
    snmp-server community "public" Operator
    snmp-server community "snmp-private" Operator Unrestricted
    snmp-server host 192.168.12.230 "public"
    snmp-server enable traps authentication
    vlan 1
       name "DEFAULT_VLAN"
       untagged 33-34,36-44,47-48,Trk2
       ip address dhcp-bootp
       no untagged 1-32,35
       exit
    vlan 11
       name "VLAN_STIPA"
       untagged 1-32
       no ip address
       tagged Trk2
       exit
    vlan 12
       name "VLAN_PROCESS"
       untagged 35
       ip address 192.168.12.13 255.255.255.0
       tagged Trk2
       exit
    vlan 20
       name "VLAN_TOIP"
       ip address 10.0.0.3 255.255.255.0
       tagged 1-44,Trk2
       exit
    spanning-tree
    spanning-tree Trk2 priority 4
    spanning-tree priority 4
    ip ssh version 1-or-2
    password manager
    

    (192.168.12.230) server:

    [root@ces:~/09:41:11]# ping -c 1 10.0.0.3
    PING 10.0.0.3 (10.0.0.3) 56(84) bytes of data.
    64 bytes from 10.0.0.3: icmp_seq=1 ttl=64 time=1.15 ms
    
    --- 10.0.0.3 ping statistics ---
    1 packets transmitted, 1 received, 0% packet loss, time 0ms
    rtt min/avg/max/mdev = 1.158/1.158/1.158/0.000 ms
    [root@ces:~/09:41:14]# snmpwalk -v 1 -c public 10.0.0.3
    Timeout: No Response from 10.0.0.3
    

    Thank you for your help!

    Hello:

    I recommend that also post your question on the Business - section switches Procurve HP Support Forum.

    http://h30499.www3.HP.com/T5/ProCurve-provision-based/BD-p/switching-e-series-Forum#.Uyr1POlOW9I

  • AIR-WLC4402-50-K9 by CLI configuration

    I have a lot of AIR-WLC4402-50-K9 devices to configure and the cli is frusterating-don't, someone at - it a link to a step by step document that crosses to assign an IP address, SSID and allowing radios using the CLI?  I can't find one that works completely.  I just need to assign an ip address, so I can use the web gui!

    Thnaks

    Here are the details...

    en

    conf t

    dot11 ssid<>

    Comments-mode

    open authentication

    end

    The above command will do it for you!

    Let me know if this answers your question!

    Concerning

    Surendra

    ======

    Please do not forget to note positions that answered your question or was useful

  • Problem with port 20 on ProCurve 2910al - 48G - POE

    I recently sent 5 x ProCurve 2910al - 48G - POE switches connected to 2 x ProCurve 5412zl.  I have a problem that port 20 does not seem to work on all 5 predisposees.  What is a config problem?

    We had the same problem

    We have upgraded to the latest version of 14.38 and seems resolved.

    probably wasn't available when you had the problem

  • WLC4402 - Questions to upgrade the AP and controller

    Hello

    I just upgraded an AIR-WLC4402-12-K9 to version 7.0.98.0 of the software, and I have a few questions-

    1. I have no APs to connect yet but when I do I'll have to check what software they run and perhaps demote the controller to get access up to v7 points?  To join the WLC v7 since v3.2 I had to make a few intermediate upgrades and I wonder if I have been a little premature and should have done updates after the APs have been associated, has new software pushed from the controller and then performed the steps in upgrade of WLC so the WLC and APs were synchronized in terms of software.

    2 - the memory usage is sitting at 60% with no associated APs.  I have just connected 4402-12 running 5.1.151.0 and he's sitting at 33% use of memory with associated access 11 points.  Have I spent in a too recent version for this controller?  What is a figure of the memory use of a 4402?

    Thanks in advance,

    Jason.

    Jason,

    A question.  You should be fine.  When the AP detects the WLC, it will do a code audit.  If this isn't the right code, it can extract the correct image of the WLC.  As long as the AP you are supported in 7.0, the recovery on the access point image won't matter.

    For question 2.  sounds of 60% of normal for 7.0, depending on the amount of memory is on the device itself.  I woulnd't ' t be too concerned about the memory usage until you points upward in the high 80 years.

    See you soon,.
    Steve

    --

    If this helps you or answers to your question if it you please mark it as 'responded' or write it down, if other users can easily find it.

  • Cisco CSA 4.2 + RADIUS + HP procurve switches

    Hello!

    We mixed network environment with cisco / HP hardware.

    We are currently assessing the Cisco ACS 4.2 to manage network access network equipment.

    Cisco equipment works very well, but we have problems the RADIUS and procurve switches (Ganymede works very well)

    I googled around and it seems that you need to create a new '(VSA, Vendor) vendor-specific attributes' for procurve switches and the IETF radius settings according to the variables on the right which must match the HP equipment.

    Problem is that I can't find this information online.

    Anyone who manages to solve this problem?

    Would really appreciate help!

    Thank you

    BR

    Generally, you should download VSA for acs. You must get the HP ini file. Once you have you need create a vsa and transfer it to acs.

    Because we need to add a specific seller attribute in the TAS, then we must first

    Create a file 'accountActions.csv' using the format specified in "RDBMS synchronization."

    Import definition', once we are ready with the file, then we must do an RDBMS

    Synchorization folder of ACS (SE) and then go on:

    Reports and activity > RDBMS synchronization and make sure that the synchronization has been

    done it without error. Once this is done, you must re - start the ACS SE, then

    We can create a new AAA client and use the new RADIUS (xxxx), and the attributes that we

    added can be made visible for:

    The interface configuration > and select the newly added Radius VSA attribute.

    : RDBMS synchronization:

    http://www.Cisco.com/univercd/CC/TD/doc/product/access/acs_soft/csacsapp/CSA

    PP40/ugse40/sad.htm#wp756877

    : Import a definition RDBMS synchronization:

    http://www.Cisco.com/univercd/CC/TD/doc/product/access/acs_soft/csacsapp/CSA

    PP40/ugse40/AG.htm

    Kind regards

    ~ JG

  • How add and configure a new controller AIR-LAP1142N-E-K9 Access Point WLAN-AIR-WLC4402-12-K9

    How add and configure a new controller AIR-LAP1142N-E-K9 Access Point WLAN-AIR-WLC4402-12-K9

    'option 43 hexagonal f104c0a80a05' looks right to me...

    If you're talking about only a few APs, you could hold the AP in the same vlan as the WLC Management Interface and allow discovery by diffusion...    Once he knows the controller you could put in a different subnet and you don't even need option 43.

    But then again, Option 43 I guess is a safe bet to ensuring that the always AP knows an IP address to find out.

Maybe you are looking for

  • iTunes didn't connect to... no valid response has been received

    I have an iPhone 6, iPhone6 more, look like iPad and iPad 2 Air in my house. Whenever I update it I get a message at the end: "iTunes could not connect to the (name of unit) because an invalid response received from the device." I AM able to update t

  • iPhone 6plus

    iPhone 6plus icloud imei no * icloud please Mr. ople < personal information under the direction of the host >

  • BlackBerry Smartphones BlackBerry Bold 9930 - where are the themes?

    «.. . just received my new BlackBerry Bold 9930 and I love it, this new cell is added my 9650 and so I like too this one breathtaking 9930 the 9650 "out of water"!  However, I like to think I'm skilled at all things BlackBerry, I am having a devil of

  • Number of IC &amp; NetMonitor Agents by host

    Get recommendations on the number of IC and NetMonitor of agents that can be run safely from separate servers?  I'm trying to reach to my hardware configuration required for an upgrade of 5.5.8 5.6.5.  Plans are to use IC officers to replace most of

  • Local storage

    Sorry in advance for the question that I'm incredibly of course is already answered somewhere in the community.I'll be installing 5.1 for a host of unique instance using the free version of 5.1 (not v-Center), the host has 12 hard drives of 250 GB an