Software iSCSI or Broadcom HBA w/TOE?

ESXi 4.1 loading on 3 Dell R710.  ESXi is picking up the 1 GB Broadcom 5709 as material hba, however nothing I tried helped me activate frames.  When I implemented the hba with frames and make a new analysis, he will not come to the MD3000i LUNS.  (The 3000i detects the hba and I added to the host in the iscsi handler... still no joy at the end of ESXi.  Also I configured ports on the 3000 to accept the extended frame).  If I leave the mtu to 1500, everything works well under hardware iscsi.

When I use the software initiator with the same NETWORK card, I can activate frames.  (Documentation is ESXi confirms that for the Broadcom, it supports IPv6 and jumbo frames, but you can't blame a guy for trying).

My question: which would give better performance?  Should I use the material hba without jumbo frames to reduce the load of iscsi, or configure software iscsi with frames?  If I understand correctly, the iscsi software has been greatly improved if I'm not really sure which way to go.

(I posted this question at the end of another thread and received no bites so I thought I would like to transfer as a new question.)  I apologize.)

As you discovered, you can really change the MTU on the HBA Broadcom adapters.

Performance is always difficult to answer.  Of course, the biggest advantage of Broadcom cards is improvement in the effectiveness of the CPU.  There are benefits to this.  Also, realize that the initiator iSCSI ESX and initiator of Broadcom can saturate a link of 1 GB for block sizes more that are useful, even in the absence of the frames.

So if you are looking for CPU efficiency, for the most part, the block sizes, the Broadcom card will use less CPU host for the same flow as the frames with the initiator of ESX.

If you are looking for a pure flow, both can fill a wire for large block sizes, and which does not change much with the introduction of jumbo frames.

Andy

Tags: VMware

Similar Questions

  • iSCSI iSCSI Software adapter or Broadcom adapter?

    This is a bit of follow up a thread on a previous post. But I noticed that my BL490c G6 5 hosts have a software adapter and Broadcom iSCSI adapt. Although I have nothing under Broadcom cards.

    Is there a difference in performance between these two? In my head, material should be better than software, but it seems software as default.

    I found this KB, indicating he may be some Fiddlers involved to get ESX to use Broadcom cards, but is it useful?

    http://KB.VMware.com/selfservice/microsites/search.do?language=en_US & cmd = displayKC & externalId = 1025644

    The iSCSI SAN is a StorageWorks P4300 G2.

    The BCM5709 equivalent and can slightly reduce the amount of work the CPU has to do, but does not support Jumbo Frames.

    If you are network switches or a table do not support frames then using the capabilities of unloading of these NICs is good.

    If frames Jumbo is supported by the two switches and table so it is best to use the iSCSI HBA software.

  • Software iSCSI configuration

    Where we get number IQN that we need to manually enter static configuration of the software iSCSI discovery.

    It depends - some have the ability to not be discovered. Give it a try, in case of doubt. If this does not work, then you will need access to the management interface or know someone who can.

  • Is there a way to remove the software iSCSI 10W?

    Hello

    We have helped the software iSCSI adapter, add 'Vitrtual Switch' and 'Port group' for iSCSI testing.

    Now, we have already deleted the virtual switch and would like to know if it is possible to remove the software iSCSI adapter?

    OR Alternatively, we can leave the adapter software there without deleting?

    Thank you

    Post edited by: TonyJK

    You can remove the software iscsi adapter by disabling everything first. Under the SWiscsi adapter > properties > configure > disable activated.

    After that, the server will request a reboot for the change.

    After this restart, swiSCSI adapter would have been automatically deleted.

    -HTH,

    zXi

  • How to add the software iSCSI adapter in vSphere, ESXi 5.0?

    Hello

    Please give me the steps to add the software iSCSI adapter in vSphere, ESXi 5.0.

    Thank you.

    Hello

    In an earlier version of VMware ESXi software iSCSI adapter was included in the list of the storage card, but is not in the case of VMware ESXi 5.0. In ESXi 5.0 iSCSI adapters are not listed by default and must be activated first before we go away from configuration.

    How to add iSCSI adapter in ESXi 5 check the link below

    http://www.google.co.in/#sclient=psy&hl=en&source=hp&q=How+to+add+Software+iSCSI+Adaptor+in+vSphere+ESXi+5.0+Site%3A+blog.srinfotec.com&pbx=1&oq=How+to+add+Software+iSCSI+Adaptor+in+vSphere+ESXi+5.0+Site:+blog.srinfotec.com&aq=f&aqi=&aql=&gs_sm=e&gs_upl=9181l21561l0l21875l33l30l4l0l0l0l736l10898l3-8.7.7.1l23l0&bav=on.2,or.r_gc.r_pw.&fp=1ad7a99e02298f12&biw=1366&bih=647

    or

    http://blog.srinfotec.com/?p=178

    concerning

    Rohit

  • find the number of map software iscsi vmhba

    Hi, im trying to write scripts for automation but I find on different server models the software iscsi adapter varies from vmhba32 to vmhba39

    Is it possible that I can find that number using powercli so I can put it as a variable to be used for another command later in the script?

    Thank you

    Forget the bug with iscsi.

    It's the derivation

    $esxName = 
    (Get-VmHost $esxName).StorageInfo.ExtensionData.StorageDeviceInfo.HostBusAdapter | where {$_.Model -like "iSCSI Software Adapter" -and $_.Status -notlike "unbound"} | Select Device
    

    ____________

    Blog: LucD notes

    Twitter: lucd22

  • ESX 3.5i / software iSCSI?

    I plan on upgrading a cluster of ESX 3.02 tomorrow to ESX 3.5.

    I would use 3.5i because of its lack of a service console, we had some problems in the initial Setup, getting the iSCSI traffic because we have an iSCSI subnet separated from our hosted customer (who is on 192.168.x.x network).

    Although I am quite familiar with 3.5i - I still try to use the software iSCSI with this version.   Can it be done?

    Sven

    It should work without problem.  You will need to create a separate vSwitch for the iSCSI network with a kernel port assigned to the iSCSI IP address range.  You will also ensure that iSCSI is allowed through the firewall.

  • Overhead costs with software iSCSI vs NFS?

    If you use NFS to store your VMS VMDK files, could say nothing about the CPU above for this, compared to the iSCSI Software?

    If you use the FC or iSCSI hardware, it seems, most of the work could be discharged at the HBA, but what about NFS that needs to be done in software? It will be easier that iSCSI from the Vmkernel doesn't have to manage the lower block level access?

    Hello.

    The difference is very small.  Check out the white paper of comparison of the performance of the Protocol storage in VMware vSphere 4 .

    Good luck!

  • No storage found on material support iSCSI cards Broadcom BCM7509C

    ESXi 5 with a port dependent on iSCSI hardware cards Broadcom BCM7509C

    Config done by the book- http://www.VMware.com/PDF/vSphere4/R41/vsp_41_iscsi_san_cfg.PDF

    I enter the address of dynamic discovery & can instantly see the correct targets in the static discovery tab, but during the execution of rescanning NO devices are

    Also, as iSCSI networks are completely isolated it didn't need a gateway, yet VC5 does NOT authorize the entry 0.0.0.0 to complain:

    The gateway IP address is incorrect. Enter a valid IP address

    It is surely not good?

    SEB

    New update corrects this, allows Jumbo frames: https://my.vmware.com/group/vmware/details?downloadGroup=DT-ESXi50-Broadcom-bnx2x-17254v502&productId=229#product_downloads

  • Link to maps software iSCSI NIC vmkernal and the vsphere client

    Hello

    IM playing with our VMware 4.1 hosts a Dell Equallogic PS4000E, connection

    So far, I have:

    Created ports VMkernal

    Apply adapters

    The iSCSI initiator enabled

    But apparently, I need to run the following command to bind the ports of iscsi software adapter:

    Add an esxcli swisscsi nic - n vmk # vmhba d #.

    Is anyway in the Vsphere Client?

    Hello.

    Unfortunately, there is no way to do it from the vSphere client.

    Good luck!

  • several software iSCSI initiators

    Hello

    I have not heard that someone does this, so just to make sure: is it possible to connect two or more without an ESX host? As far I knew each SAN would require its iSCSI initiator, but I only know how to activate the default initiator and not add multiple.

    Thanks for your reply,

    -Rainer

    Yes, it is possible to connect multiple iSCSI targets to the iSCSI Software initiator.

    Create several VMkernel ports bind to the iSCSI initiator.

    • Connect vmhba34 to vmk1: esxcli swiscsi nic add - n d vmhba33 vmk1

    • Connect vmhba34 to vmk2: esxcli swiscsi nic add - n vmk2 d vmhba33

    • Check the configuration of vmhba34: esxcli swiscsi nic list vmhba33 d

    • Vmk2 and vmk1 should be listed.

    It is normally used to provide multiple active paths to iSCSI storage.

    You can also create additional VMkernel ports for more than one iSCSI SAN network.

  • Error in adding an iSCSI LUN - use software iSCSI initiator...

    Hi guys,.

    I can't add an iSCSI LUN to my host ESX4.0. It is the iSCSI Software initiator that is activated and I can see the LUN after I launch a new analysis.

    While adding the LUN as a data store, it throws me an error, please find the attached for the snapshot file.

    The real question is if I add a lun iSCSI and then remove it and again try to re add it whether or nor the old signature are found that do not readd it.

    Is there a command that I can use to remove all the LUNS already assigned and delete it existing signatures.

    Let me know guys if the above is not clear.

    Kind regards

    Use fdisk to create a partition and vmkfstools - C command to format the partition as VMFS. You use a supported storage array?

  • Hardware ISCSI does NOT work but the software ISCSI works...?

    We have a HP MSA2012i ISCSI SAN and our ESX hosts are DL380 g6 with dual-port HBAS (Qlogic QLE406Xc) were also running ESX 4.0 and vCenter.

    I can see the cards under my storage adapters, but when we do an ANALYSIS of new LUNS they do not appear. We checked it wasn't a problem to switch by plugging directly on the MSA modules.

    Also, I went in the HBA BIOS and did a scan "for devices" and nothing comes up.

    I found the next thread that describes exactly the issue im having except that everything ive tried they describe does not work for me...

    http://communities.VMware.com/thread/221303

    What Miss me?

    Very well. Have you tried to use the Qlogic iSCLI utility to resolve the problem? You can download the vmkernel corresponding to the new analysis journal? Thank you.

  • How to use 4 x 1 GB for software iSCSI NETWORK interface card.

    Hello. I have a HP P2000 G3, with iSCSI connections 4 x 1 GB. I have 4 free 1 GB NIC on my 5.5 esxi server. IM wondering how I could put things upwards, so it would use iSCSI 4x1Go at the same time, so I would get a 4 Gbps to my SAN connection. Is this possible? I read something about iSCSI multi-trip and Port binding, but is all a bit confusing. It seems to me which is used for failover? I tried to put in place using a multipathing guide and got to the top and his display I 8 paths to my SAN, but it seems that a NETWORK adapter is used when considering my switch activity.

    Any help would be appreciated.

    Take a look at this blog post: http://www.virtualtothecore.com/en/howto-configure-a-small-redundant-iscsi-infrastructure-for-vmware/

  • Initiators of software iSCSI Microsoft Cluster in guest

    Hi guys

    I have a client who have iSCSI Storage... now they want to create a cluster, but I read that only FC SAN is supported for RDM...

    but it seems that iscsi is supported as iscsi in guest...

    If someone knows the configuration for this?

    or is it as simple as:

    1. create iscsi volume of Quorum

    2. create iscsi for data volumes

    3 activate the iscsi initiator in Windows 2008 guest VM

    4 map these to W2008 VM iscsi volume

    5. create an another PortGroup-VLAN for the private heartbeat (is it necessary or the private sector can take thje same segment as the notrmal network)?

    Thank you very much

    Oh, sorry I didn't answer your original question.

    You are right, you must configure the virtual computer with 3 vNIC on 3 different subnets, then make sure that the public network is on top, when configuring the network order in the BONE (don't know where it was in 2008 for Windows, in Windows 2003 is configurable in the advanced network settings) Guest.

    André

Maybe you are looking for

  • Freelancer multi player ID does not

    I just installed an old game. FREELANCER wanted O play online with a friend. I bought 2 copies and we installed. to play online, the game gives an identification number. copy of my friend gave him a number. However, mine is not. our computers are ver

  • Installation office 2013 family & student fails

    Hello I have an Icona w4-820 and it was supposed to be sold with preinstalled office. It didn't, but I managed to get the correct installation of MS program using the identifier for the product that I found in the box. Setup stops somehow after a few

  • How can I reformat a media card

    I have a ScanDisk Ultra II, when I put it in my hp731oxi, I get a memory card error error message?

  • cannot adjust the volume of the speaker on CDMA devices reader

    The normal code for the volume of the speaker, who works on GSM devices does not work on CDMA devices. VolumeControl volumeControl = (VolumeControl)this.player.getControl( "VolumeControl" ); if( volumeControl != null ) volumeControl.setLevel( 20 ); I

  • SNA on the primary is less than on previous day

    Hello guys, talk like that in this forum but there are ways to solve this problem and I need to know if it should be solved or not.I created the physical standby and it worked very well. created archive_log files had Yvert number exactly as primary,